10 Best Cocktail Shaker Sets in 2020: Reviews and Buying Guide

bar tools cocktail cocktail shaker


Table of Contents

List of 10 Best Cocktail Shaker Sets in 2020


A cocktail shaker, no matter what type it is, the main function of it is to properly integrate the ingredients of a cocktail, martini, shot, or any drink that has 2 or more ingredients into one deliciously flavored drink. A good bar should not go without this tool. 

This lists the top 10 (plus 2) of the best cocktail shakers in the market to help you decide from the countless (and enticingly beautiful) shakers. But beware that beauty doesn’t equal performance and efficiency. So, check this list for suggestions.

Our Choice

To help you more, here’s our personal choice - the Boston shaker. We consider it one of the best cocktail shakers because of the ease of use and cleaning. The absence of a built-in strainer is easily solved with the purchase of a separate Hawthorne strainer that fits most shaker cups. A lot of Boston shakers are now sold in sets so you need not fret.

Things to Consider When Buying a Cocktail Shaker

There is no one set of rules on how to choose the best cocktail shaker. Here are a few tips to consider when buying your cocktail shaker. Make sure to read them to make the best purchase decision. 

1. Level of expertise

    Consider your level of expertise when buying your cocktail shaker. For budding bartenders, the cobbler shaker is a good start since it does not need advanced skills to use. For professionals, they prefer the Boston shaker although the French shaker is making its way to more bars.

    2. Purpose

      You can use a  cobbler shaker at your home bar since it will be used occasionally. For busy bars, the Boston shaker set is the best choice since it can be used to mix several drinks because of its large content, ease of use, and ease of cleaning.

      3. Design

        Aesthetics play a small role in choosing a cocktail shaker set but it sure does not hurt to choose something that is easy on the eye. You work with it every day, it pays to choose a tool that you are most comfortable with. Something that will suit your home bar. 

        A good weight should also be considered, depending on your preference. Weight adds rigidity to the shaker and helps for a more comfortable and quieter shake. Find one that’s comfortable to use without compromising quality.

        4. Material

          Choose stainless steel material since it is durable, chills drinks easily, and sounds good. The glass cup of the Boston shaker can be good but its downside on durability makes us reconsider buying the set with glass cups. 

          Plastic is a no-no if you are a professional because it defeats the purpose of fast chilling and it sure sounds terrible. You don’t want to work with something that can potentially damage your ears. Okay, that’s a bit too much but you get it.

          Copper shakers are also a no-no in professional bars because it is not dishwasher-safe. You have to take extra measures to keep it looking good or you need to throw it out unless you want to gross out your patrons.

          5. Versatility

            Select a cocktail shaker set that can be used through the years and for all types of cocktails. While choosing the best cocktail shaker, make sure you are looking at it for long term use. 

            6. Capacity

              All good cocktail shakers are usually large enough so it can accommodate a large volume of ingredients, especially the ice to chill your drinks. A 28-oz Boston shaker cup is a good choice.

              Difference between a cocktail shaker and a Boston shaker?

              The Boston shaker is a type of cocktail shaker. There are actually three kinds of cocktail shakers in the market now.

              The Boston Shaker

              The Boston shaker is composed of two separate cups, sometimes two of steel or one steel and one glass. The newer ones are usually made of stainless steel because it is not prone to breakage. One of the cups is weighted for more efficiency. 

              What we love about it

              • Seldom gets stuck
              • Easy to seal and reopen
              • Easy storage due to its conical shape
              • Usually comes in similar sizes so when one cup is damaged, it is easy to purchase a replacement, not the whole set
              • When using a glass cup, it is easy to see the cocktail inside
              • Can be shaken using one hand as long as it is sealed tight
              • Easy to clean

              Downsides

              • Need for a separate strainer
              • Needs more practice to master
              • Plain looking
              • The glass part of the shaker is prone to breakage

              Cobbler Shaker

              The type of shaker is a user-friendly shaker that needs no extra practice to perfect its use. It is slightly smaller than the Boston shaker and is best for single drinks. These are great cocktail shakers for the bar at your home. 

              What we love about it

              • Easy on the eye with the different designs 
              • Three-piece construction is easy to assemble
              • Comes with a built-in strainer
              • Cap can be used as 1oz jigger
              • Less dilution as it uses less ice
              • Easy to use for beginners

              Downsides

              • Built-in Strainer has large holes
              • Prone to leaking and spillage
              • Not suitable for recipes calling for eggs due to dirt traps around the cap
              • Prone to freezing if used in quick succession

              French Shaker 

              The French or Parisian Shaker is a hybrid between the cobbler and Boston shaker. With just two parts, eliminating the built-in strainer of the cobbler and incorporating a cap instead of another cap to the Boston shaker, this is also one beautiful shaker you will surely love.

              What we love about it

              • The set comes with a 17 oz cobbler shaker, Hawthorne and julep strainers, muddler, bar spoon, and 2 liquid pourers
              • Black matte finish for a classy style
              • Also comes with a cocktail recipe 
              • Made of high-quality stainless steel
              • Scratch-resistant
              • Sturdy and durable
              • Chill drinks fast
              • Easy on the eye
              • Seals tightly
              • Easy to clean
              • No dirt traps

              Downside

              • Can be difficult to open
              • Needs a separate strainer
              • Handwash only

              How do you properly shake a cocktail?

              1. Whatever is your choice for a shaker, it is the shaking that determines its success. Follow these steps to properly shake your cocktail. 
              2. Add the ingredients.
              3. Close your shaker until you get a proper seal. Make sure the lid is tight. 
              4. Hold on to the parts of the shaker to avoid accidents and mess.
              5. Give it a good, vigorous shake until condensation appears on the outside of the shaker, about 15-20 seconds. However, some recipes call for shorter shaking, especially if it does not have sugar or other solid ingredients that need dissolving or a lot of dilution.
              6. Opening the cocktail shaker can be a bit tricky. The cap for the cobbler shaker can get stuck or the smaller cup on the Boston or French shaker may need a whack to open it up.
              7. Always use the appropriate strainer to avoid pouring the ice or bits of fruits into the cocktail. Always use new ice if the cocktail needs to be served with ice. Do check if your shaker has a built-in strainer.  

              List of the 10 Best Cocktail Shaker Sets in 2020

              1. Cressimo Cocktail Shaker Set

               

               

              Pros:

              • Amazon bestseller
              • Easy assembly; screw-on cap lessens getting stuck
              • 24 oz capacity
              • Comes with a double jigger, bar spoon 
              • Free cocktail recipe cards
              • Made of high-quality steel alloy
              • Durable and sturdy
              • Dishwasher safe
              • 2-year worry-free warranty

              Cons:

              • Lids and tops get stuck
              • Some say it leaks
              • Rusts easily

              What customers are saying about the product:
              Cory said the product was just like what was described, despite what he read in some reviews, he took a leap of faith and trusted the product. In the end, he wasn't disappointed (1st photo). Rebeccah says she will be buying more products from the seller of this product since the product is very durable, easy to clean, and looks great on her new bar (2nd photo). 

              Why we think this is a great product:

              The product is made of high quality material making it sturdy and it'll last for a long time. It has features that lessens the problem of the cap getting stuck, you can just toss this in your dishwasher and it'll come out great and clean. Plus, it comes with free cards of cocktail recipes, isn't that a bonus? 

              Who should buy it:

              This product is good for beginners and for people who just make cocktails for them. The set only includes three basic tools, unlike the rest of the products on the list but this is still a great find, quality-wise. 

              2. Modern Mixology Bartender Kit with Stand

              Pros:

              • Comes with a stylish wooden stand for easy storage
              • Comes with the basic tools in the bar - cobbler shaker, Hawthorn strainer, tongs, spoon, jigger and bottle opener - no need to buy individual items
              • Free cocktail recipe cards
              • Made of high-quality steel alloy
              • Dishwasher safe
              • A good choice as a gift for cocktail lovers
              • 100% customer service guarantee (money-back guarantee)

              Cons:

              • Actual size is smaller than advertised
              • Some reports of missing pieces in the set
              • Some say it leaks

              What customers are saying about the product:

              Arielle first stated that she loves this set, it has everything that was described and contrary to some reviews, every tool has a spot. The steel used is stainless and it doesn't leak. She highly recommends the product (1st photo). Morgan got this cocktail shaker for his new bar and he is happy with the quality and the price of this set (2nd photo).

              Why we think this is a great product:

              This has all the basic tools you need for your cocktails, you don't need to spend more money on buying the tools individually. On top of that, the tools are high quality and they come with a customer service guarantee.

              Who should buy it:

              For some people, organizing is hard and a waste of time, if you're guilty of that, this product is convenient for you as it comes with a wood stand to make the storing part easier. 

              3. Appolab 18oz Cocktail Shaker Bar Set

              Pros:

              • Comes with other tools for a complete bar set up - cobbler shaker, jigger, spoon, muddler, tongs, and 2 liquid pourers for less messy pouring
              • Versatile use
              • Stainless steel cocktail shaker
              • Sturdy and durable for high volume use
              • Scratch-resistant and anti-dents
              • 550ml (18oz) capacity

              Cons:

              • The top hardly comes off
              • Bottle stopper slides
              • Some reports of leaking and missing pieces

              What customers are saying about the product:

              Carla Craig stated that it's nice to have all of the pieces in this set, she never thought she needed it to make certain cocktails. She enjoys using this product and she thinks it has a lot of potential as a present. (1st photo). Jie Zhao sees this product as a very good quality product and the price is also very reasonable (2nd photo).

              Why we think this is a great product:

              This also provides you the basic tools you need to create any cocktail recipe you want. What makes it unique is it is anti-scratches and anti-dents, you won't have to worry about ruining its beauty when you're making a cocktail.

              Who should buy it:

              If your hands are not too careful but still want to maintain the beauty of your cocktail shaker and tools, this would be ideal.

              4. Elite Cocktail Shaker Set by Barillo

              Pros:

              • 24oz capacity for efficient preparation of cocktails
              • Shaker Set comes with cobbler shaker, muddler, spoon, double jigger, and 2 liquid pourers
              • high-quality stainless steel cocktail shaker with high grade inner for chemical-free drinks
              • Comes with a velvet bag for easy storage and travel
              • Comes with an exclusive cocktail recipe booklet and ebook for new techniques, tips, and recipes
              • 100% money-back guarantee

              Cons:

              • The lids get stuck and they're hard to remove 

              What customers are saying about the product:

              Bridget Lacy, a customer, commented that the set is classy, easy to use, and wash. It looks beautiful in her bar and it would always be a great gift to family and friends (1st photo). Adam thinks this is an outstanding product that comes with an outstanding customer service (2nd photo).

              Why we think this is a great product:

              This is a safe cocktail shaker set because of the sophisticated steel used and the high grade inner, now you get to enjoy chemical free drinks. It comes in a velvet bag that is easy to carry, you can bring this along during travels in case you and your family or friends decide to stop and have a drink for a while. It comes with a recipe book, that's something to look forward to. 

              Who should buy it:

              If you're just starting to learn how to be good at making cocktails, this product could help you. It ensures a safe drink, gives you complete tools, and the book that contains tips, tricks, and recipes.

              5. Perfect Home Bartending Kit with Gun Metal Bar Tools

              Pros:

              • Classy black shaker set comes with shaker, spoon, Hawthorn strainer, ice tongs, double jigger, muddler, bottle opener, and 2 liquid pourers
              • Comes with a rustic wooden crate tool holder that can be hung for easy storage and access
              • Made of high-quality material and rustproof
              • free access to the exclusive online catalog of cocktail recipes
              • Hand wash only
              • Best for people that have a home bar
              • Comes with 3-year extended warranty for your peace of mind

              Cons:

              • Bad delivery reports
              • Early signs of chipping
              • Some tools don't fit the wooden crate
              • Hand wash only

              What customers are saying about the product:

              Amazon Customer found the set great looking, it goes well with his/her newly built bar in his/her home. The tools are of great quality, the customer can't wait to show off this new addition to his bar (1st photo). Anni says this is the best thing she ever got from Amazon (2nd photo). 

              Why we think this is a great product:

              The dark color of the set really suits it, it looks elegant and the wooden crate also contributes to its whole aesthetic. You won't need to worry about rusting with this product and it comes with a guarantee. 

              Who should buy it:

              If you own a mini bar in your lovely home, this would make a great display even if you don't want to use it. It gives out this classy and rustic vibe. 

              6. Premium Cocktail Shaker Set by Top Shelf Bar Supply

              Pros:

              • Comes with 28oz weighted cup and 18oz unweighted cup
              • Designed for spill-free shaking
              • Stainless steel cocktail shaker set
              • Sturdy and durable
              • Dishwasher safe

              Cons:

              • Edges are too thin and sharp
              • Two pieces are hard to separate, they get stuck 
              • Some reports of missing pieces

              What customers are saying about the product:

              Abraham Ikoviskey said that the product is the kind of set that he has been looking for for a while now, he finds it very pleasing. The material is sturdy and the seal is tight and never leaks, he also made a point that the customer service is excellent (1st photo). Lee Tilden added a photo of her cocktail shaker that she says is very good for its quality and price (2nd photo).

              Why we think this is a great product:

              This only comes with a cocktail shaker, if you're looking for the complete set, try another product. This product is great because it doesn't spill, spills are some bartender's pet peeve, this shaker might actually help you. Not to mention, it's sturdy and it's safe to put inside the dishwasher. 

              Who should buy it:

              If you're looking for a high quality cocktail shaker only, this is perfect for you. It is worth your money and won't disappoint. The material is pretty thin though, it gets cold quickly, if the cold bothers you while making a cocktail, maybe get a thicker one.

              7. Vinobravo 12-Piece Boston Cocktail Drink Shaker Set

              Pros:

              • Comes with 28oz weighted cup and 18oz unweighted cup
              • perfectly weighted for balance and ergonomics
              • Designed for a tight seal for spill-free shaking
              • Comes with a Hawthorne strainer, mesh strainer and julep strainer
              • Also comes with ice tongs, muddler, double jigger, spoon, and 2 liquid pourers
              • Includes a booklet of cocktail recipes
              • Made of high-grade stainless steel, thicker than most options in the market
              • Sturdy and durable
              • Dishwasher safe
              • 100% risk-free customer satisfaction guarantee
              Cons:
              • Shaker tins may get stuck
              • Some reports of missing or damaged items
              What customers are saying about the product:

              Patrick purchased the product and felt so excited to try them out and practice any flair tricks with them. He claims that this product is heavy duty and said this purchase was worth it (1st photo). Leo said this is the first set he bought and it both works and looks great (2nd photo). 

              Why we think this is a great product:

              This product is arguably the best you'll get, it contains the complete set of tools, the material used is high grade, it is thick, it stays durable, it doesn't spill, it includes a guarantee, and if you want to try other recipes you haven't tried? You get to have a recipe booklet and experiment with alcohol.

              Who should buy it:

              If you're looking to find a worthy set, get this. It offers a complete package from the number and types of items it includes to the quality of the items, it is sturdy and it works well with its job. It's low maintenance so you can just wash everything in your dishwasher. To put the cherry on top, it offers a risk-free customer satisfaction guarantee!

              8. Aloono Drink Shaker, 11-Piece Bar Set Cocktail Maker

              Pros:

              • This bar set Comes with 28oz weighted cup and 18oz unweighted cup
              • Designed for a tight seal for spill-free shaking
              • Comes with a Hawthorne strainer, mesh strainer and julep strainer
              • Also comes with ice tongs, muddler, double jigger (4 measurements) bar spoon, and 2 liquid pourers
              • Made of stainless steel
              • Sturdy and durable, will not rust or warp even in high-volume use
              • Dishwasher safe

              Cons:

              • The color outside is just vinyl wrap
              • Shaker top and bottom get stuck together and hard to come apart
              What customers are saying about the product:

              Willian P. Murray bought this set and they arrived in perfect condition and the product lived up to its description. The company also responded promptly to his request, he overall loved the product  (1st photo). Gaylon Waylon got a silver replacement for his copper shakers and he has been very happy with it since it feels solid and works perfectly (2nd photo).

              Why we think this is a great product:

              The set gives you complete tools needed for cocktails, and they are all sturdy and they get the job done perfectly - a requirement for making great cocktails. The silver looks simple and elegant. You best believe this set is worth your money. 

              Who should buy it:

              This is actually a great find for anyone wanting to buy a new set of cocktail shakers and other tools but there are problems with the dark colored set, it'd be better to get the silver one. 

              9. Mixology Bartender Kit by Mixology & Craft

              Pros

              • The set comes with a cobbler shaker, double jigger, ice tongs, Hawthorne strainer, muddler, spoon, bottle opener, and 2 liquid pourers
              • Also comes with a wooden stand for easy storage and access
              • Designed for a tight seal for spill-free shaking
              • Made of stainless steel
              • Scratch-resistant
              • Sturdy and durable
              • Handwash only
              • Three-year 100% product warranty
              Cons:
              • Handwash only
              • Some reported that it rusts easily 
              • Some found the shakers small
              • The steel is pretty thin
              What customers are saying about the product:

              Lauren G is very glad she made her purchase. She thinks the whole set is beautiful, the wood is sturdy and real. She loves how the product came with a warranty. She highly recommends the product (1st photo). Ron bought this set for his would-be bartender brother-in-law and Ron says he is very happy to put it to use (2nd photo).

              Why we think this is a great product:

              The tools are complete and sturdy, the set has outstanding features such as it is spill free and scratch resistant but not only does it get the job done but it also looks perfect as a display in your bar or it would be a beautiful gift to someone you know. It comes with a wooden stand which makes it stand out more. 

              Who should buy it:

              If you're looking for an item to make as the fresh sight in your bar, this product is worth it. Making it a display becomes a more reasonable cause for purchasing it since the tools are smaller than they seem and it rusts quickly.

              10. Premium Cocktail Shaker Set by Trendy Bartender

              Pros:
              • The set comes with a 24 oz shaker, 12oz shaker, and a double jigger
              • Black and silver finish fits in any bar setup
              • Also comes with a cocktail recipe eBook for easy access anywhere
              • Made of stainless steel
              • Scratch-resistant
              • Sturdy and durable
              • Dishwasher safe

              Cons:

              • Tops may come off easily or get stuck
              • Black paint chips after some time
              What customers are saying about the product:

              Nicki stated that this product is a great set, she said it is extra frosty, it seals great, and works well with the dishwasher. She absolutely loves this product 1st photo). Bentbrook also bought this set and he is especially happy with the small shaker although this is the first time he used this size (2nd photo). 

              Why we think this is a great product:

              The looks of this product is satisfying, the black accents make it unique and different from the usual silver shakers. You can have a free cocktail recipe ebook when you purchase this product, you can access it anytime you want. It also defies scratches so you don't have to worry about that.

              Who should buy it:

              This is for people who have the rest of the tools except for the cocktail shaker and a jigger, it doesn't come with the complete tools but the product itself is amazing, it works perfectly. 

              FAQs

              How its use began

              Tradition has it that the first cocktail shaker used as a bar tool were actually just two glasses, much like the Boston shaker is now. The first patent for the cocktail shaker was owned by W. Harnett in 1872.

              What is the Purpose of a Cocktail Shaker?

              What is a Professional bartender without the cocktail shaker? This is one of the most essential bar tools that make a cocktail mixed well, chilled, and diluted. 

              Mixing

              While stirring will do the mixing, who doesn’t love a professional bartender doing some tricks with the cocktail shaker? Shaking, however, hastens the dissolving process of sugar and other ingredients that need to be dissolved. When stirring, the drink will be watered down before the sugar is fully dissolved. That is one problem that the shaker has solved. How are cocktail shakers able to do this? The ice speeds up the movement of the liquid inside the shaker.

              Chilling

              The stainless steel material of the shaker chills the drink in less time compared to other materials such as glass or plastic. The ice in the shaker also moves around the shaker during the shaking process, making the drink colder in a short time.

              Dilution

              For the best cocktail to taste as it should, it needs to take on water without diluting it too much. Without the ice during the shaking process using chilled ingredients, the cocktail may be mixed and cooled but not diluted, it will come out too strong and nothing like the cocktail you were used to.

              Why does my cocktail shaker get stuck?

              There are three reasons why your shaker gets stuck: when some syrup got between the cap and the body and when the metal has contracted because of the very low temperature in case of the cobbler shaker, or when the cups don’t match in the case of the Boston shaker.

              To unstick the shaker, your best bet is to soak the shaker in hot water. The hot water will work with the solidified syrup that got your shaker stuck and allow the shaker to return to its original size due to the heat. To prevent stuck-up shakers, use 2 to alternate so the shaker doesn’t get too cold. You can also soak the shaker in hot water after a few uses. A few seconds of soaking will be good enough.

              For the Boston shaker, give it a few whacks on the tilted part of the cup to try to straighten the tilt and remove the stuck cup. Be sure to use matched caps to prevent this.

              What size is the ideal cocktail shaker?

              The cocktail shaker comes in different sizes - 18oz to 28oz. In the case of Boston shakers, the bigger cup usually ranges from 20oz to 28oz while the smaller cup is usually 12oz to 16oz. This is the biggest capacity for the shakers. For cobbler shakers, the smallest is at 16oz and the biggest is 24oz. Be sure to select something that is comfortable to use, especially if you have smaller hands.

              How do you properly shake a cocktail?

              1. Whatever is your choice for a shaker, it is the shaking that determines its success. Follow these steps to properly shake your cocktail. 
              2. Add the ingredients.
              3. Close your shaker until you get a proper seal. Make sure the lid is tight. 
              4. Hold on to the parts of the shaker to avoid accidents and mess.
              5. Give it a good, vigorous shake until condensation appears on the outside of the shaker, about 15-20 seconds. However, some recipes call for shorter shaking, especially if it does not have sugar or other solid ingredients that need dissolving or a lot of dilution.
              6. Opening the cocktail shaker can be a bit tricky. The cap for the cobbler shaker can get stuck or the smaller cup on the Boston or French shaker may need a whack to open it up.
              7. Always use the appropriate strainer to avoid pouring the ice or bits of fruits into the cocktail. Always use new ice if the cocktail needs to be served with ice. Do check if your shaker has a built-in strainer. 

              Conclusion

              On that note, Choosing the best cocktail shakers is the quintessential tool for successful bars. The essential chilling and slight diluting of your favorite cocktails usually depends on the cocktail shakers. So, next time you want to whip up a good drink, be sure you have a hood shaker at hand. Happy drinking!


              Older Post Newer Post


              • Solange on

                I purchased The French or Parisian Shaker 2 years ago and it did not last very long. The painted finished started to peel off even though we only hand-washed it. Please do not recommend it. I am looking for a replacement and I want to see a list of products that have been tested through time and use, not ones that just look nice.


              Leave a comment

              Please note, comments must be approved before they are published

              Related Posts