15 Best Soda Makers in 2020: Review and Buyer’s Guide



Table of Contents

  • Our Top Picks

  1. Best SodaStream: SodaStream Fizzi One Touch Sparkling Water Maker
  2. Best Starter Kit: SodaStream Source Sparkling Water Maker Starter Kit
  3. Best Design: Aarke Carbonator II
  4. Best Handheld: iSi Steel Soda Water Siphon
  5. Best Versatile: Drinkmate Spritzer Portable Sparkling Water and Soda Maker Drink
  6. Best Overall: DrinkMate IDRIP-Free Carbonating Bottle
  7. Best Value: SodaStream Fizzi Sparkling Water Maker Bundle
  8. Best for Small Kitchen: IKICH Sparkling Water Maker
  • Runner-ups

  1. KitchenAid KSS1121OB Sparkling Beverage Maker, Onyx Black
  2. Nuvantee Soda Siphon
  3. Impeccable Culinary Objects ICO011 Soda Siphon
  4. Spärkel Beverage System Sparkling Water and Soda Maker
  5. SodaStream Aqua Fizz Sparkling Water Machine with CO2 & Glass Carafes
  6. FIZZpod Soda Maker
  7. SodaSparkle Home Soda Maker Kit

Why add fizz to water? In 2018 alone, about 800 million gallons of sparkling water were sold in the United States alone. While water is still the best beverage, not many prefer it from the tap, unchilled especially during the summer months. However, soda is the culprit for many decayed teeth, elevated blood sugar, and other health problems. To enjoy the fizz without the health complications, make your own soda water. Here we rounded 15 soda makers in the market to help you make a better choice. 

Benefits of Soda Maker

Companies producing soda makers insist on the long-term value of making your own soda at home. 

1. Convenience

Making soda beverages in the comforts of your home any time of the day is a very good selling point for this product. Whether it can just make soda water or other beverages, it is still a good addition to any kitchen for soda lovers.

2. Big Savings

You can save big when you have your own soda maker at home since you don’t need to go to the grocery to buy your favorite soda. All you need is to have a replacement CO2 cartridge when yours is all used up. 

3. Environment-friendly

You also save on the use of plastic bottles by reusing the canisters. Since you are more likely to be using tap water than bottled water then you can dramatically decrease the number of single-use plastic bottles and aluminum cans that find its way to bodies of water resulting in pollution and harm to marine life. In fact, one bottle of CO2 cylinder (60L)  can potentially reduce up to 3,000 single-use plastic bottles or cans. That’s a lot less carbon footprint there. 

4. Healthier Choice

Instead of drinking sugary drinks, you can control the amount and type of sugar or sweeteners to use in your beverages. Research also shows that kids who drink carbonated drinks are more hydrated than those who don’t. As long as you monitor the amount of sugar in those homemade carbonated drinks then you should be fine. 

Buying Guide

Here are a few tips you might consider when buying a home soda maker machine. 

1. Setup

You can choose between a handheld or countertop soda maker. If you have a very small counter space, buying a handheld soda maker can be a good choice. However, if there are 5 of you who drink soda at least twice a day, then a countertop setup is a better option since it can make more soda in a shorter amount of time.

2. Source and storing of CO2 cylinders

Since CO2 is a consumable, you need to stock up on it if you are using a handheld soda maker. Find a soda maker that has the nearest available seller and gives you the most value. It should also be kept between 50-70oF (10-21oC) to keep it from bursting due to an increase in pressure. 

3. The time needed to carbonate drinks

Handheld soda makers make soda water a lot longer than countertop soda makers because the countertop ones have more power to it. Also, countertop makers can make more soda water in one go compared to handheld soda makers. Different brands take slightly different lengths of time to make a single batch too. 

4. Versatility and value

There are soda makers in the market now that can carbonate beverages other than water. If you like to carbonate almost anything, look for this type. They are a bit pricier than the regular soda maker but are totally worth it. 

5. Design

If you have a small counter space, find something that is sleek but functional. The design also entails ease of cleaning. Taking apart a soda maker to clean can be hard but a well-designed soda maker will take cleaning into consideration.

15 Best Soda Makers

Here are 15 best soda makers in the market today that are most endorsed by many reviewers and users. 

Our Top Picks

To narrow down your choice, we corralled 8 best options for the category you are considering. 

1. Best SodaStream: SodaStream Fizzi One Touch Sparkling Water Maker

SodaStream Fizzi One Touch Sparkling Water Maker - AdvancedMixology

Pros

  • Backed by SodaStream reputation as the pioneer in homemade soda
  • The set comes with 60-L CO2 cylinder and 1-liter reusable carbonating bottle
  • Three buttons for controllable fizz levels 
  • Replacement CO2 cylinders available on SodaStream online shop, Amazon, and other online stores

Cons

  • Quality control issues like the wrong item were delivered to the customer and missing items
  • Costly refills given the delivery fees from the SodaStream online shop

What customers are saying about the product: 

Laura, an Amazon customer, says she and her husband received this (1st photo) as an anniversary gift and it’s very easy to use plus they don’t add more soda cans to the dump. She is happy to be saving her money from this soda maker. Tam and his family love fizzy water and now he hopes to save on time and money since he can make his fizzy water in the comforts of his home. It’s easy to use and gives just the right carbonation (photo 2). 

Why we think this is a great product:

We love it for its sleek design that is small enough o set up even in small kitchen counters. 

Who should buy it:

Fizzy water lovers out there, grab one now! If you feel you spend so much on soda and soda water, make your own at home. 

                                      

2. Best Starter Kit: SodaStream Source Sparkling Water Maker Starter Kit

SodaStream Source Sparkling Water Maker Starter Kit - AdvancedMixology

Pros

  • Good starter kit
  • Makes soda water in seconds
  • Portable and no batteries or electricity needed
  • Free mini-carbonator makes 9 liters of sparkling water
  • Fits a standard 60-L carbonator cylinder
  • CO2 cylinder available from the SodaStream website, Amazon, and other online shops

Cons

  • The bottle overflows when you add fizz even if you keep the water less than suggested
  • Shorter warranty than the older version

What customers are saying about the product: 

Michael loves this soda maker but finds the replacement cylinders expensive so he decided to modify his and get it fitted with a 20-lb CO2 bottle (1st photo). Scott did the same modification on his soda maker (2nd photo) but with a smaller 5-lb tank. 

Why we think this is a great product:

We love it for its portability. No need to complain of being off the grid when you have this soda maker. 

Who should buy it:

Campers and outdoor-lovers will love adding this to their camping stuff. At just less than 8 pounds, that’s one luxury you can enjoy aside from adding fizz to your lovely spring water at your campsite. 

                                         

3. Best Design: Aarke  Carbonator II

Pros

  • Lovely design with its stainless steel finish and no-mess base
  • Available in 4 color finishes
  • No electricity or batteries needed
  • The kit comes with a carbonator and 1-L PET bottle
  • Uses standard 60-L CO2 carbonators
  • Replacement cylinder and bottles can be bought online

Cons

  • No free CO2 cylinder upon purchase
  • Expensive carbonator
  • Uses PET bottle, not totally plastic-free 

What customers are saying about the product: 

For Bill, the lovely finish and design of the Aarke II Carbonator he got on Amazon is just the flash of color his dark counter needs. He also loves the vintage feel of the lever instead of buttons. The price is worth all the garbage he made buying those single-use bottled water and the recycling it would require. The downside is that it uses a PET bottle (1st photo). Tom, another Amazon customer also loves the finish and the ease to set it up. It works well with standard soda maker cylinders so he loves it. 

Why we think this is a great product:

We think this is a great product because it works efficiently and the CO2 cylinders are easily accessible from online stores. Big savings than buying soda water every day. 

Who should buy it:

If you want to join the war against the dump, make your move and make your own soda water. 

                                         

4. Best Handheld: iSi Steel Soda Water Siphon

iSi Steel Soda Water Siphon - AdvancedMixology

Pros

  • Sleek design and classic colors
  • Handheld and portable, 1 pound only
  • Easy to use
  • Small chargers can be placed in a purse or picnic basket
  • 1 charger can carbonate up to 800ml of pure water

Cons

  • Carbonates cold water only
  • Flimsy material 

What customers are saying about the product: 

Hemanth Pai loves that she can have soda water anytime even when she is on the go with this portable soda maker she got from Amazon. The trick is to chill the siphon and fill it with cold water to get the most out of your soda maker. Jason, on the other hand, the trick is not to overfill the soda maker to avoid mishaps in the kitchen. He has designated a glass marked with the right amount of water to refill.    

Why we think this is a great product:

Portability is the best asset of iSi Steel Soda Siphon. 

Who should buy it:

Everyone who loves soda water on the go will love this. 

                                           

5. Best Versatile: Drinkmate Spritzer Portable Sparkling Water and Soda Maker Drink

Drinkmate Spritzer Portable Sparkling Water and Soda Maker Drink - AdvancedMixology

Pros

  • The set comes with infuser, 500ml bottle and two 10L CO2 cylinders
  • Portable, no batteries needed
  • Easy to use
  • A great alternative to soda 
  • Can carbonate almost any drink
  • Works on the 60L CO2 cylinders

Cons

  • The 10-L CO2 chargers are not available on Amazon but can be ordered on the DrinkMate website
  • Returns not allowed

What customers are saying about the product: 

Thomas loves to add fizz to just about anything, including his fruit and vegetable infused water and the 500ml bottle is just the right for his needs. He loves using the DrinkMate spritzer he got from Amazon because of its design and functionality. Jordy also loves the small design and is a perfect alternative to countertop soda makers. It’s also great that you can control the degree of carbonation. 

Why we think this is a great product:

Even if the smaller 10L CO 2 bottles are not available on other online stores, the fact that it works on a 60L cylinder is a great idea. You can reserve the smaller cylinders for camping and use the bigger cylinder for home use. 

Who should buy it:

Campers, off-the-grid, and picnic goers who love soda so much but want to wean from it for health reasons are very welcome to buy this soda maker. 

                                        

6. Best Overall: DrinkMate IDRIP-Free Carbonating Bottle

DrinkMate IDRIP-Free Carbonating Bottle - AdvancedMixology

Pros

  • Revives flat soda or beer
  • Works with any standard 60L CO2 cylinders
  • 2-year no-fuss warranty
  • The set comes with a 10L CO2 cylinder

Cons

  • The 10-L CO2 chargers are not available on Amazon but can be ordered on the DrinkMate website
  • Returns not allowed 

What customers are saying about the product: 

Why we think this is a great product:

If it gives new life to our soda, who are we to say no? And it’s sleek, pretty, and works on any standard 60L cylinder, that’s a total win for us. 

Who should buy it:

Soda lovers unite! Let’s show this soda maker some love!

                                         

7. Best Value: SodaStream Fizzi Sparkling Water Maker Bundle

SodaStream Fizzi Sparkling Water Maker Bundle - AdvancedMixology

Pros

  • The kit comes with the Fizzi sparkling water maker, 3 1-L reusable bottles, 2 60-L CO2 cylinders, and 2 zero-calorie flavorings
  • Sleek design in classic black

Cons

  • Produces flat soda 
  • Poor customer service
  • Defective products delivered

What customers are saying about the product: 

Gina says the value of the SodaStream bundle (1st photo)  she bought from Amazon is awesome and it makes her life easier given that she buys club soda all the time. Miracle Lady also loves her purchase on Amazon because it will replace her favorite lemon-lime soda and the hassle of carrying heavy bottles. She’s finally getting rid of all the calories and sugar without giving up on flavors. 

Why we think this is a great product:

We think this is a good product since you can make your flavored soda with the zero-calorie flavorings that come with the bundle. That's taste plus fizz minus the calories is a winning equation for us.

Who should buy it:

Those who don't want to deal with multiple sellers to get everything they need for a zero-calorie soda they can drink anytime and serve on any occasion. 

                                          

8. Best for Small Kitchen: IKICH Sparkling Water Maker

IKICH Sparkling Water Maker - AdvancedMixology

Pro

  • Slim and sleek design perfect for small kitchens with small counter space
  • The kit comes with a soda maker and 2 1-L BPA-free bottles
  • Can use any standard 60-L CO cylinder
  • The Automatic Pressure Release will release the airing button as soon as the soda water gets enough carbonation
  • Can fit bottles from other soda makers 

Cons

  • The kit does not come with a CO2 cylinder
  • Does not sell the Ikich bottles separately

What customers are saying about the product: 

Amazon customer, Dr. B said the item was shipped immediately after purchase and he loves his new carbonated drink machine. Crystal Kim says it a great soda maker at an affordable cost.  

Why we think this is a great product:

We think that it's a great product since it can make soda water super fast without skimping on quality.

Who should buy it:

When you don't have enough counter space or enough budget to get a bigger soda maker, this is your best bet in the market. 

                                          

Runner-ups

Here are some good choices you should also consider before deciding to buy your soda maker. 

9. KitchenAid KSS1121OB Sparkling Beverage Maker, Onyx Black: Modern design, vintage look 

KitchenAid KSS1121OB Sparkling Beverage Maker, Onyx Black - AdvancedMixology

Pros

  • The set comes with a 60-L standard CO2 cylinder and a 1L PET bottle
  • Available in 8 colors to choose from - contour silver, empire red, onyx black, aqua sky, cobalt blue, green apple, tangerine, and white
  • It also comes with a pressure gauge so you don’t add too much carbonation to your water. 

Cons

  • Too much pressure may cause the bursting of the bottle
  • Difficult to return for refunds or replacement of the item

What customers are saying about the product: 

Scott says that the KitchenAid Soda Maker (1st photo) he got from Amazon is a great product and though there are some design glitches that can be improved, he still gave the product 5 stars because he cannot find a better machine. Dan also got a standing mixer of the same brand (2nd photo) and he loves how it matches the theme of his kitchen, very classy yet functional. 

Why we think this is a great product:

The vintage design of this soda maker combined with the pressure gauge to ensure safety and economy are the primary selling points of this soda maker for us. 

Who should buy it:

When you want to go for classy without breaking the bank, this is the soda maker for you. 

                                           

10. Nuvantee Soda Siphon: Versatile soda siphon that can be used for NO2 chargers



Nuvantee Soda Siphon - AdvancedMixology

Pros

  • Inexpensive but functional
  • dishwasher-safe
  • uses standard CO2 charger
  • comes with a free e-book for cocktails
  • Large capacity, 3-4 cups of water
  • Can be used as for NO2 chargers

Cons

  • Longer carbonation time, 15 minutes

What customers are saying about the product: 

VK is happy with the soda siphon that she got from Amazon and instead of waiting for just 15 minutes, she leaves her sparkling water overnight in the siphon. Making a quart of soda water in 15 minutes is not really a big sacrifice at all for her. Jake, another content Amazon customer, loves how it works perfectly well after using it in a play to hose another actor with it. 

Why we think this is a great product:

Though it takes longer to make soda water than the usual stuff, the fact that it can be fitted with a NO2 charger for creamy and over-the-top cocktails is a great idea. 

Who should buy it:

If you're patient enough to wait for 15 minutes to get your soda water, this soda siphon works well for you. 

                                      

11. Impeccable Culinary Objects ICO011 Soda Siphon: Sleek soda siphon that's functional and attractive

Impeccable Culinary Objects ICO011 Soda Siphon - AdvancedMixology

Pros

  • Retro design 
  • Easy to use, sturdy, and efficient
  • Reliable soda maker
  • Very good quality product

Cons

  • Carbonated water sometimes turns out flat
  • Single-use CO2 cartridges
  • Hard-to-see contents

What customers are saying about the product: 

Stephanie loves her ICO soda siphon she bought from Amazon because it's portable and she thinks it is a great addition to her stainless steel kitchen accessories. Chargers are affordable so you can make carbonated water all the time. Seoulfull, another satisfied Amazon customer, said she loves chilling her siphon and adding freezer-cold water to make her amazing seltzer. 

Why we think this is a great product:

We love it for its portability and it's a fun way of adding fizz to your wine spritzes without the added sugar and calories because you're only adding carbonated water!

Who should buy it:

When one makes occasional fizzy water for cocktails indoors or during picnics, this is the perfect tool to bring with you. 

                                        

12. Spärkel Beverage System Sparkling Water and Soda Maker: Adds fizz to your flat beer or soda



Spärkel Beverage System Sparkling Water and Soda Maker - AdvancedMixology

Pros

  • 5 levels of carbonation to control the amount of fizz
  • It can also be used in adding fizz to a lot of other beverages - fruit juice, wine, tea, herbs, spirits
  • Adds fizz to your flat beer, soda, and other carbonated drinks
  • Available in 5 colors you can choose from
  • Works on a patented Carbonator A+B pack, not a CO2 cylinder which is available on online stores

Cons

  • Not enough instruction on the use
  • Missing parts upon delivery

What customers are saying about the product: 

An Amazon customer (first photo) said she loves sparkling water but not the waste of cans and she likes it that she can choose the level of carbonation since she doesn't want them to be too harsh. She's happy with level 3 of carbonation. Annamarie, another Amazon client, says she bought this as a present for herself and she's happy to make her own filtered water flavored with organic fruit. She's making savings and reducing her carbon footprint while having the best-tasting water to boot (second photo). 

Why we think this is a great product:

It's faster than most carbonators and the bottles look really nice. Plus, we save on having to swap the CO2 cylinders every time we need a refill. The carbonator packs have recyclable packaging so that's one less problem to deal with.  

Who should buy it:

If you think that sending the CO2 cylinders over for refills then waiting for delivery is too much of a hassle, you may want to try this carbonator set. 

                                       

13. SodaStream Aqua Fizz Sparkling Water Machine with CO2 & Glass Carafes: Environment-friendly soda machine with glass carafes

SodaStream Aqua Fizz Sparkling Water Machine with CO2 & Glass Carafes - AdvancedMixology

Pros

  • Set consists of one unit soda maker, 60L CO2 carbonator, and 2 glass carafes
  • No need for batteries or electricity
  • Uses standard 60L CO2 cylinder
  • The glass carafe can be washed in the dishwasher

Cons

  • Prone to leaking
  • Glass carafe breaks easily
  • Unstable design

What customers are saying about the product: 

Rated Jay, an Amazon customer, says it is easy, cost-effective, and eco-friendly. It's a great update from the older versions without the guilt of still using the plastic bottles (both photos). Jeremy, another customer is happy that though it can only carbonate water, it still makes his favorite Kool-aid and Mio better than drinking it using plain water. 

Why we think this is a great product:

First of all, it uses glass carafe so it means less plastic though as glass is naturally more fragile than the usual PET bottles. Another is it's operated manually so you can control the amount of fizz you want. It can "burp" some of the excess carbonation so you can try until you get the right carbonation level you're comfortable with.  

Who should buy it:

Earth warriors who hate all forms of plastic, rejoice! Here's SodaStream's answer to your not-so-silent prayers. 

                                           

14. FIZZpod Soda Maker: sleek and convenient soda maker

FIZZpod Soda Maker - AdvancedMixology

Pros

  • It comes with 1 carbonator, 3 PET bottles, 3 caps, 1 fizz infuser, and a manual
  • Lightweight and convenient to use
  • Add fizz to your flat beverages
  • Can be used for any drink
  • Uses standard 60L cylinder 

Cons

  • Does not come with a CO2 cylinder; be sure to get one when you order it
  • Uses PET bottles

What customers are saying about the product: 

Celeste is one happy Amazon customer since it delivers the kind of fizz they need for their products. She uses it in product demonstrations for their company and they're able to carbonate almost everything from fresh juices to cocktails. The results are also consistent since they use a carbonation tester for each beverage they add fizz and it comes out with similar results. Lynne is also happy with this soda maker since she's not stuck to one CO2 cylinder company and she's enjoying the taste and fizz from her current supplier. 

Why we think this is a great product:

What used to be negative on this product became an opportunity to try other CO2 cylinder brands. 

Who should buy it:

Anyone who loves a slim and compact but functional soda maker will be happy with this product. Plus you can make lots of drinks without having to empty your bottles since there are three in the set. 

                                       

15. SodaSparkle Home Soda Maker Kit: compact home soda maker you can carry anywhere

Pros

  • Compact and handheld
  • The carbonators are disposable and recyclable
  • The kit comes with a charger-activating cap, reusable BPA-free bottle, 5 disposable soda chargers, and nozzle cap
  • Tight cap to keep the carbonation in

Cons

  • Replacement chargers can be expensive
  • Some sets were delivered with expired reusable bottles

What customers are saying about the product: 

CatnJak recommends this soda maker she got from Amazon after their first unit gave out after 3 years of use. She had some issues with the first use but after fixing it with a simple trick of rinsing with hot water, her soda maker is working just fine. JGTango tried keeping his drinks after carbonating it and after three days, the water has not gone flat. 

Why we think this is a great product:

While it demands a brand-specific charger, we can use the standard CO2 chargers by adding a penny or paper shim to wedge in the charger. It's great since it's designed in an unobtrusive way. 

Who should buy it:

This is the real on-the-go soda maker since you can use the bottle directly, no need to transfer to a different bottle. 

                                          

FAQs

1. Are soda makers worth it?

Cost per liter, there is not much difference between homemade soda water compared to commercially bottled ones. Depending on the brand, it could either be slightly more expensive to make soda water. However, the benefits can be far-fetched since it dramatically reduces the number of plastic bottles that end up at sea. Recycling costs money too so soda makers may not save that much money but can potentially save the environment. 

However, if you are buying drinking water by the bottle, then the same bottles can have the same fate as the soda bottles, thus defeating the point of reducing the carbon footprint. In the end, the answer to the question remains with the consumer. While it is delightful to drink sparkling water, it is not that important. The worth of the soda maker lies in the fact that we have consumed this kind of beverage like our life depended on it when in reality it does not. 

Another issue of soda makers is convenience. While it can be convenient to make your own sparkling drinks at home, it is not always that convenient. Not all soda makers are versatile enough to be used in other beverages such as juices. Also, you should always use chilled water to make your sparkling water. 

2. Does sparkling water make you fat?

There is no evidence that carbonation and being gassy are related. However, artificial sweeteners found in soda water or zero-calorie soda can actually make you gassy. If you like drinking directly from the bottle or through a straw, you might be guzzling gases together with your beverage, resulting in a bloated feeling, eventually making you feel gassy. 

3. Is it cheaper to make your own sparkling water?

Makers of carbonators argue that it is safer to make your own sparkling water rather than drinking store-bought ones, especially if you are using your own tap water. 

4. Is carbonated water bad for your kidneys?

The whole point of adding carbonation to water is to make it more enticing. Studies show that children who drink carbonated water are better hydrated than those who drink plain water. The added sweetness plus the carbonation also makes you more satiated. For this reason, research also showed that people who drink carbonated water are less likely to rehydrate after exercise. This could potentially hurt your kidneys, having to flush out the toxins from the body without the aid of proper hydration. 

On the other hand, research shows that there is strong evidence linking carbonated beverages with kidney problems and other lifestyle diseases such as diabetes and hypertension. While cola beverages are the guiltier party, carbonated water using artificial sweeteners is not altogether in the clear. Research is divided on this issue, though, some claiming that artificial sweeteners can have aggravating effects on diabetes, which ultimately hurts the kidneys. However, without any aggravating issues, some artificial sweeteners should be safe enough. 

5. Can kids drink sparkling water?

Yes, kids can drink sparkling water. In fact, a few studies show that kids who drink sparkling water are more likely to stay hydrated than those who don’t. However, the downside of it is that sparkling water can potentially replace other healthy drinks such as milk and natural fruit juices. The carbonation can also cause bloating, resulting in sluggish and uncomfortable movement of the kids. So when it comes to kids, especially younger kids where habits are most likely to be formed, allowing them to drink sparkling water should be an issue that should be taken judiciously. Habits formed in youth can lead to life-changing decisions in the future.

Conclusion

Finding the soda maker that will work well both for your budget can be a bit daunting with the many options you have in the market. Try some cocktails using club soda or soda water such as the classic mojito

Sign up to our free VIP club to avail of our exclusive rebate program. No credit cards required. No need to purchase anything. We just want to say thank you.



Older Post Newer Post


Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published

Related Posts