11 Best Ice Trays in 2020: Buying Guide and Reviews



Let’s be honest, our favorite beverages become so much better when they are ice cold. And perhaps the quickest way to make a cold drink is to add a bunch of ice cubes to it made from an excellent and handy ice tray. While some people think that ice may water down their drink and therefore makes them bland, they should note that this only happens when the ice melts fast. A cold drink is best consumed at a normal pace that gets you refreshed without having deteriorated flavors. Having an ice tray is very useful at home, bars, cafes, and other establishments that produce the best cold or frozen drinks. If you want to enjoy a refreshing drink wherever and whenever then buy an ice tray now! 

Buying Guide

Here are several factors to consider when buying an ice tray. 

Design 

The standard ice cube tray has branched out to different shapes and styles. Most of them still follow the tray-style with numerous compartments. New styles feature insulation boxes and unconventional shapes that are meant to make the drink look cooler. Because of these new features, they may require more effort to be used correctly. 

Material

Ice trays can be made from plastic, silicone, stainless steel, or a combination of them. Each has its advantages and disadvantages. Stainless steel is durable but they don’t produce the perfect shapes. Silicone makes removal of ice easy but sometimes they give an unpleasant smell from the material or odors absorbed in the freezer. Plastic ones can make many ice cubes but tend to break when twisted too much in trying to get the ice out. Nevertheless, they all work great when used properly. 

Size

Most plastic trays make average-sized ice cubes and even smaller ones. Silicone trays are more catered towards big ice cubes as well as different shapes like the spheres because of their flexibility. The size you want will depend on the purpose that the ice will serve. If you’re using it solely for home purposes, you can use standard ice trays. But, if you like to serve drinks on the rocks, the big ice cubes and spheres are the best ones. 

Capacity

Ice takes a long time to freeze depending on the size which is also related to the capacity. Some ice trays work well but the downside is that they only make 2-4 at once and considering the freezing time, it may not be as efficient unless you have more molds. Some trays can make 16+ ice cubes but they tend to melt fast. If you’re hosting a large party, the standard ice trays are ideal but if you’re serving scotch to several friends, you can use the silicone ones. 

Price

One always has to consider the price when buying something. Your choice of ice tray must fit within your budget and if you’re willing to invest in expensive ones, make sure they are of high quality to make them worth it.

Top Picks 

11 Best Ice Trays

If you want to buy a great ice tray that suits your needs, here are the 11 best ice trays to choose from. 

1. Best Overall: Kitch Ice Tray - Carefully made with quality food-grade materials by skilled tradespeople, ensuring easy removal of ice
                

Pros:

  • Made with FDA-approved, BPA-free, high-density Polyethylene plastic
  • Made in the US,  no foreign unregulated plastic
  • Best for home use
  • Dishwasher-safe (top rack)
  • Stackable

Cons:

  • Sometimes have defects
  • Can crack when too frozen 
  • Trays can stick when too frozen
  • Not flexible

What customers think about this product:

Walton, an Amazon customer, commends this product for its durability. He’s had his trays for 9 months already but they’re still in good condition. He fills his tray a little below the separator line and lets them freeze (1st photo). When the ice freezes together, he just simply twists them and the ice cubes break up individually. Another customer commented that these trays are the best that she’s ever owned because they last longer than her old ones. The ice next to the trays (2nd photo) is the end product.  

 

Why we think this is a great product: 

At one glance, Kitch ice trays may look like the average ice tray you can find anywhere and if you do think of them as such, you are mistaken. Made from quality materials, these trays produce ice cubes that are easy to remove and are perfect for home use. They may look simple, but they are convenient. 

Who should buy this?

If you’re looking for an all-around ice cube tray, this product is a great choice as they have the perfect size for shaking cocktails, blended drinks, and juices. 

                            

2. Best for Home: OMORC Ice Tray - Made with LFGB-certified and food-safe materials for easy removal of ice without twisting the tray

                   

Pros: 

  • The white frame is made from Polypropylene (PP) material
  • Green bottoms are made from Thermoplastic elastomer (TPE) material
  • Each tray makes 14 nice-sized ice cubes (total of 28)
  • Comes with spill-resistant, removable lids
  • Stackable
  • Good for home or bar use
  • User-friendly
  • Dishwasher-safe
  • Easy removal of ice
  • Very affordable

Cons:

  • The tray can crack when too frozen

What customers think about this product:

A particular customer who is an avid tennis player says that this tray is amazing at creating the perfectly-sized ice cubes for his water bottle to keep him dehydrated. He also appreciates the individual lids and the stackability feature (1st photo). On the other hand, Valentina uses these trays to make baby food for her daughter and says that they are great (2nd photo). She also said that the cubes are easy to remove despite other people’s opposing comments and she suggested leaving the tray for a few minutes at room temperature and it will be effortless to remove them. 

 

Why we think this is a great product: 

They may seem like ordinary ice cube trays but their bottoms are silicone which makes the ice cubes easier to remove with a simple push. There’s no need to twist. And the lids also protect the ice from adopting certain odors and water drips from the freezer. These trays are also great for frozen foods. 

Who should buy this?

Anyone who needs a cheap and quick way to make ice cubes for home or cocktails at the bar, this product is for you.  

                             

3. Best for Bars: Adoric Ice Trays - Made with Non-toxic and Durable Silicone to create perfectly-shaped Ice Cube and Sphere

             

Pros:

  • Made with high quality and odorless silicone
  • 2 different molds in a set
  • Makes 6 (2-inch) ice cubes and 6 (1.8-inch) ice spheres 
  • Great Value
  • Flexible tray for easy removal of ice
  • Sphere tray is leak-proof with elevated edges to prevent adhesion
  • Can withstand a temperature up to 446 degrees Fahrenheit
  • Doubles as a baking tray

Cons: 

  • Sphere trays are difficult to fill
  • The lid doesn’t create a tight seal 
  • Lack of clear instructions on how to use 

What customers think about this product:

Nick, an Amazon shopper, commented that this product is quality made. He used his trays for a party and his guests were having drinks on the rocks and it went great(1st and 2nd photos). These trays saved him money from buying bags of ice. Craig, another customer, said that these trays are cool and he loved the size and the fact that they keep the drink nice and cold (3rd photo). 

 

Why we think this is a great product: 

One of the luxuries in enjoying whiskey and other strong cocktails is to serve them with a big ice cube. This way, the alcohol won’t be diluted as fast because the ice will melt slower due to its size. You can choose between an ice sphere or ice cube but with the Adoric ice trays, you can make both at a very affordable price.

Who should buy this?

These ice trays make an awesome gift to your dads or to anyone who enjoys whiskeys. More importantly, this set is perfect for those who love both big ice cubes and spheres. 

                             

4. Best for Water Bottles: Lily’s Home Ice Stick Tray - Strategically designed for making long and slim ice 

             

Pros:

  • Made with BPA-free silicone
  • Makes 10 (3.75-inch) ice sticks (total of 30)
  • Great for water bottles with narrow mouths
  • Available in fun and bright colors
  • Great value
  • Freezes quickly 
  • Pops out easily

Cons:

  • No lids
  • Not stackable

What customers think about this product:

Granny uses these trays to make frozen broth (1st photo) as dog treats as well as lemonade sticks for iced tea. She remarked these are easy to use and clean and budget-friendly. 

Peg also likes the nice slim ice cubes (2nd photo) and thinks the only downside is that they're not stackable. 

 

Why we think this is a great product: 

On a hot day, it would be nice to drink cold water from your bottle but it’s a bit frustrating if the ice cubes don’t fit in the bottle because the mouth is too small. Worry no more because Lily’s Home ice tray is the solution.

Who should buy this?

This is ideal for people with water bottles meant for traveling or sports because the ice sticks optimally fit in them and keep the drink or water cold.

                             

5. Best for Entertaining: Glacio Clear Sphere Duo - Creates Perfectly Clear Ice Spheres 

                 

Pros:

  • Made with BPA-free non-toxic, thick silicone
  • Has a plastic insulation box
  • Makes perfectly round clear ice
  • Great for bar and home use
  • Ice melts Slower
  • Easy removal of ice
  • 100% guaranteed replacement

Cons: 

  • Only makes 2 ice spheres at a time
  • Takes a long time to freeze (24-30 hrs.)

What customers think about this product:

Frank commented that this mold is amazing. He suggested following the directions correctly to achieve the perfect sphere always (1st photo). He also used filtered water for better results and he said that 24-28 hours is the ideal freezing time.  MH, another Amazon customer, shares the same thoughts. He put the ice sphere in a glass of water to see just how clear it is. (2nd photo). He uses warm water and freezes them in 30 full hours and he claimed that they all came out perfectly. 

 

Why we think this is a great product: 

Creating ice spheres at home is great, but creating clear ones is more awesome and sophisticated. If you’ve only had clear ice spheres at a fancy bar, now, you can make your own at home to impress your guests and yourself. This mold guarantees to make flawless ice spheres every time. 

Who should buy this?

For the whiskey lovers who want the best way to enjoy their drinks the best and elegant way, this ice mold is the solution. 

                            

6. Most Innovative: True Cubes Ice Tray - Specially Constructed to make Big Crystal-Clear Ice Cubes

                

Pros: 

  • Made from BPA-free plastic and silicone
  • Comes in 3 parts, including an insulator
  • Makes 4 (2”x2”x2”) ice cubes
  • Ice melts slower
  • Can purify tap water
  • Great for bars
  • Can use regular tap water or other kinds
  • Easy to use

Cons:

  • Expensive 
  • Takes about 18-21 hours to freeze
  • Takes up much space in the freezer
  • Can be tricky to remove ice at first

What customers think about this product:

 A customer named Mauldin expresses that this purchase is worth it (1st photo). He shares that when he brought this tray to a friend’s house, his friend had already bought 6 ice cubes for $10. Then, he did the math and said that he could make 24 ice cubes with the $40 price but beyond that, they would be for free. Meanwhile, MLo said that he highly recommends the product because of how easy it is to use and the way it makes crystal clear ice easily (2nd photo). 

 

Why we think this is a great product: 

With this tray, you can make clear ice cubes without having to boil water because its special construction is said to purify tap water and remove 95% of metals and total dissolved solids (TDS). They also don’t alter the drink’s taste but simply enhances it by making them cold longer. 

Who should buy this?

If you’re the kind of person who likes drinks on the rocks, this tray is perfect for you because the ice doesn't water down the drinks and it makes the drink look pristine because of its clarity. 

                            

7. Coolest Shape: Shaped Skull Ice Maker - Creatively-designed to mimic Skulls For a More Awesome Drink

               

Pros:

  • Made with food-grade, BPA-free, non-toxic silicone
  • Patented, cool skull shape
  • Makes 4 (2”x2.36”) ice skulls
  • Ice melts slow
  • Can be used for other food items
  • Easy to use
  • Dishwasher-safe

Cons: 

  • Poor seal
  • Some people found it difficult to create skull shapes due to lack of instruction

What customers think about this product:

Young, an Amazon customer said that this product is very cool and she suggested cutting the holes on top of the mold bigger for better use(1st photo). Another customer said that the skulls came out well-defined and the mold is easy to use and they freeze quickly (2nd photo). 

Why we think this is a great product: 

It’s not every day that you can come across a drink with cool-looking ice, that's why the 3D Skull Mold Tray is a keeper. Considering that a skull has intricate details, silicone is the best material for it so it is easy to remove. It’s also versatile because aside from ice, you can make other skull-shaped food like chocolate, candies, cakes, and jello. This also makes a great gift to anyone who loves to drink alcohol in style.

Who should buy this?

This is perfect for the whiskey lover as they are unique and they make the drink look cooler. You can also make flavored ice for cocktails with this mold. 

                             

8. Arrow Home Products Ice Trays - Create Fun size ice and food items for Home and Personal Needs

    

Pros:

  • Made with food-safe and BPA-free polypropylene plastic
  • Each tray makes 60 small gumdrop-shaped ice (about 1 tsp.) 
  • Perfect size for sports bottles and portable blenders
  • Designed with stacking lugs
  • Can be used for other food items
  • Freezes quickly
  • Dishwasher-safe
  • Great for home use

Cons: 

  • Trays can crack when too frozen 
  • Can be difficult to remove ice
  • Ice melts fast due to size

What customers think about this product:

Most customers appreciate the tiny size of the ice, like Nicole who said that she can enjoy beverages without the bulkiness of traditional ice cubes and she can chew them easily (1st photo). Some customers expressed some concerns about getting the ice out and the structural integrity of the plastic. Jvsunsol, another customer suggested to not overfill the trays so the ice can come out easily by simply twisting the trays (2nd photo)

Why we think this is a great product: 

Have you ever wanted to fill your sports water bottle or portable blender with ice but the ice made from your regular-sized ice tray won’t fit and is just too big to be blended? Well, now you can with the Arrow Home Products ice tray. The ice may be small but at least you can make many at once (total of 180). They can also be used from molding candies, chocolates, frozen broth, coconut oil, baby food, etc. 

Who should buy this?

If you want to take a break from those huge ice cubes, you can try smaller and cute ones, and these trays are a great and inexpensive way to achieve it. These are also great for all those ice munchers out there. 

                             

9. Tovolo Ice Sphere Molds - 2-part Molds with Innovative design to create perfect ice Spheres Easily

                         

Pros:

  • Made with BPA-free and food-grade materials
  • Has 2 parts: plastic and silicone
  • Silicone is designed with thin edges to create the seal
  • Makes 2 (2.5-inch) ice spheres
  • A hole at the top for expelling excess water
  • Easy to Use
  • Ice melts slower
  • Easy removal of ice

Cons: 

  • Doesn’t create clear spheres
  • Some customers complained about not fully formed spheres 

What customers think about this product:

Elegant ice spheres, what’s not to like? Artie commented that this product is great for the price (1st photo). Another customer, Joseph, was skeptical at first because of the low price but when he got to use them, he loved them and said he will purchase a set again (2nd photo). 

 

Why we think this is a great product: 

Tovolo ice sphere molds let you create perfect ice balls for your favorite drinks and to impress your guests. Ice spheres also reduce the chance of scratching glasses or shakers due to the absence of ragged edges. 

Who should buy this?

Whether for home or bar purposes, this product is sure to keep the flavor profile of the drink, keeps them cold and impresses your guests 

                             

10. RSVP International Endurance Ice Tray - Built with Stainless Steel for Quick and Odorless Ice cubes

                   

Pros: 

  • Made from 18/8 durable stainless steel
  • Makes 6 (1.5”x2”x2.5”) ice cubes
  • Great for home drinks and other food items
  • Ice melts slower
  • Has a lever handle with dividers for easy removal of ice
  • Does not absorb any odor 
  • Dishwasher- safe

Cons:

  • The handle is not as durable as the tray
  • Last row ice cubes tend to stick together

What customers think about this product:

Most customers love this old school style tray because they are sturdy and they don’t leave a smell or taste like from other silicone molds. One particular customer said that he loved this product and he would buy it again. He also thought that this would make a great Christmas gift for anyone who likes large ice in their drinks. 

 

Why we think this is a great product: 

You can experience the retro way of making ice cubes with this solid and easy to use stainless steel ice tray. Practically, you just fill it up with water, let it freeze and you simply just pull the lever to separate the cubes. Your drinks will stay cold longer without excess dilution and unpleasant tastes so you can enjoy your drink every time.  

Who should buy this?

If you want to make big ice cubes quickly at home the old fashioned way, this product is a terrific choice because they’re quick and can be used for other frozen foods. 

                            

11. Samuelworld Ice Cube Trays - Create Big Ice Cubes Efficiently at Home or Bar 

                         

Pros: 

  • Made from premium, food-grade BPA-free silicone
  • Each tray makes 8 (2”x2”x2”) ice cubes (total of 16)
  • Ice melts slower
  • Easy removal of ice
  • Dishwasher-safe
  • Great for home and bar use
  • 100% Lifetime Warranty 

Cons: 

  • Some customers complained about white films in the ice
  • Flimsy when the tray is being carried to the freezer

What customers think about this product:

April purchased these trays because she said the plastic ones always crack and become brittle. She said that these are flexible and she loves the color and the size of the ice cubes. In every drink, she only needs to use 1 ice cube to keep it cold (1st photo). Meanwhile, Shawn had used these trays for making flower cubes for a baby shower and said that they were a hit (2nd photo). Other customers commend this product because they easily release the ice cubes that melt slowly.

 

Why we think this is a great product: 

This product can create 16 big ice cubes at once at a very affordable price and they are convenient and easy to use. The ice cubes may not be clear but they retain the shape and they melt slower for less dilution of the drinks. 

Who should buy this?

To those who want to make large ice cubes for their whiskey at home, these trays will do the job quite easily. They are also great for bar use. 

                              

FAQs

Why do silicone ice trays smell?

Silicone molds or trays may be flexible but one thing people don’t like about them is that they pick up smells from the freezer easily and affect the drink’s taste. Some silicone trays are advertised as odorless and while this is true, a few months later, they would still absorb the different strong smells from the freezer like from your leftover food or from the soap that you wash it with. Others will smell like rubber or plastic right from the start because of some chemicals. 

How do you clean ice trays?

Some trays are dishwasher-safe but if you want to ensure that your trays are thoroughly cleaned and prevent them from breaking, wash them by hand with hot water. Soap may not be a good idea because the smell tends to linger and can latch into the ice the next time you make them. 

You can also use a water and baking soda solution. 

  • Combine 2 teaspoons of baking soda and ½ cup of water and fill the trays with it. 
  • Let it sit for a few minutes, then scrub the compartments with a cloth or soft-bristled brush, ensuring the corners. 
  • Rinse thoroughly with hot or warm water. 

How do you keep ice from sticking to the ice tray?

A big mistake that people make when removing ice is that they will remove them immediately when they’re still frozen solid. Some even try to twist too hard which results in ultimately breaking the tray. A good trick to easily remove the ice from the tray is to let them sit at room temperature for a few minutes or to run the tray with hot water to break the seal that keeps the ice attached to the tray. If you’re making normal-sized or smaller ice cubes, don’t run them in hot water for too as they will melt. 

How can you make clear ice using a standard ice tray?

Some ice trays feature a special insulation box to make clear ice effortlessly. But, if you’re just using a standard ice tray, you can also make them too. The best way to do it is to boil water as this will remove the impurities and air bubbles, let it cool a bit and fill the trays with it. Cover the tray so there will be no unwanted particles mixed and then freeze. If you don’t want to boil water, you can just use distilled water. Another way is to place the ice tray, filled with water, in a cooler. The cooler should be filled with water that’s enough to surround the bottom of the tray. Don’t put a lid on the cooler and place it in the freezer. 

Conclusion

There you have it, folks, the best ice trays you can get. Whether you’re making ice in the kitchen, at the bar, or for parties, they will not let you down but instead, make your beverage endeavors fun and convenient. Big ice cubes are best for whiskeys and where better would you serve them than in whiskey glasses? Click here to find the best whiskey glasses. Meanwhile, blended drinks or frozen cocktails require ice and blenders and you can find the best blenders right here.

Older Post Newer Post


Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published

Related Posts