15 Best Bloody Mary Mixes In 2021: Reviews & Buying Guide

Cocktail Mixers & Other Essentials Reviews

Bloody Mary cocktail with three mixes beside it

When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. For more information on how we conduct reviews, click here.

The complex combination of ingredients that make up the iconic bloody mary cocktail is vodka, tomato juice, Worcestershire sauce, black pepper, celery salt, Tabasco, and lemon juice. Given its number of components, it can be a bit of a hassle to create if you don’t have much time. Thankfully, bloody mary mixes were invented.

You can reduce the long list of ingredients to just two: the bloody mary mix and vodka. If you’re intrigued, check out the lineup of the best bloody mary mixes below.

Our Top Picks

Mr & Mrs T Original Bloody Mary Mix
Mobile Button

Best Single-Use - Mr & Mrs T Original Bloody Mary Mix 

• 5.5 fluid oz.
• Great for traveling
• It can be enjoyed as is

Best Set - Demitri's Bloody Mary Mixes

• 8 fluid oz.
• Variety pack
• It can be used for cooking

 Most Versatile - Bloody Revolution Gourmet Mixes

• 32 fluid oz. 
• Excellent spice level
• Traditional bloody mary ingredients

1. McClure's Bloody Mary Mixer - Best for Gourmet

McClure's Bloody Mary Mixer
check price button
 Pros Cons
  • 32 fluid oz. 
  • Flavorsome
  • All-natural
  • Right consistency
  • Good value
    • Some may not like the pickle flavor
    • May require other ingredients to make a traditional bloody mary

     What Customers Have To Say

    One Amazon customer shared that she has used McClure’s for six years because it’s the best bloody mary mix for her. She finds the pickle juice strong, so she adds a little tomato juice to round it out. She also likes the spice level. 

    Another customer said that this bloody mary mix is packed with flavor, and no horseradish is even better. The brine from the pickle juice and dill pack a punch that most mixes lack. Overall, he’s delighted with it and will be buying it often.

    Why We Think It’s Great

    A traditional bloody mary uses horseradish and Worcestershire sauce as one of the main components. But you won’t find these in McClure’s. Don’t worry because it compensates with a punch of pickle, briney goodness for a burst of saltiness and tanginess. If you are looking for a nice twist on a bloody mary, this is it!

    Who Should Buy It

    If you prefer kosher and gluten-free beverages, look no more because this is the best bloody mary mix for you. It can also be consumed as is if you don’t have alcohol or other ingredients on hand. 

    2. Master of Mixes Extra Spicy Bloody Mary Mix - Best Value  

    Master of Mixes Extra Spicy Bloody Mary Mix

    check price button
     Pros Cons
    • 33.8 oz fluid 
    • Great spiciness
    • Gluten-free 
    • Dairy-free
    • Only needs alcohol
    • The heat may mask some flavors 
    • Saltier than other mixes

    What Customers Have To Say

    An Amazon shopper stated that he likes some heat in his BM, and this bloody mary mix certainly fits the bill. He usually adds some celery salt and a little cayenne pepper just to kick it up a notch. He recommends this if you like a well-balanced mixer. 

    A different customer shared that she bought this mix for her wedding and everyone kept asking for her bloody mary recipe. Little did they know that she only added vodka and pickled asparagus to the drink. It was well worth the purchase for her.

    Why We Think It’s Great

    If you can’t get enough spicy food or drink, you have to try this bloody mary mix. It has a 5-pepper blend: jalapenos, de arbol, habanero, chipotle, and ancho chili peppers. Added with a tinge of lemon juice and a whole lot of tomato juice, you get a delicious drink with a kick. Of course, you have the option to add your favorite vodka to enjoy the experience fully. 

    Who Should Buy It

    If you have a high spice tolerance and genuinely enjoy an excellent spicy drink with a load of tomato flavor, then this is the best bloody mary mix that you’re looking for. 

    3. Tabasco Bloody Mary Mix - Best Spicy 

    check price button
     Pros Cons
    • 32 fluid oz. 
    • Excellent for cocktails and mocktails
    • Consists of classic bloody mary ingredients
    • No preservatives or stabilizers
    • Gluten-free
    • A bit salty
    • It could be more flavorful

    What Customers Have To Say

    One customer was worried that this bloody mary mix would just be Tobasco poured in his drink, but it was not. He tried it and said that it has an incredible flavor and was worth the try. 

    Another buyer said that he’s a big fan of everything Tabasco. This is the most homogeneous bloody mary mix he has found, and the taste is superior to all the other brands. He also likes topping off beer with it, which was the original German bloody mary recipe when vodka was in short supply.

    Why We Think It’s Great

    Hailing from festive Louisiana, Tabasco is among the best ingredients for a bloody mary. Specializing in bloody mary mix, they took after the original bloody mary made by a bartender named Fernand “Pete” Petiot at Harry’s New York Bar in Paris. They then blended the flavor with the classic Tabasco sauce.

    Who Should Buy It

    You shouldn’t miss this bloody mary mix if you are a solid Tabasco fan. You probably had much food to eat flavored with Tabasco hot sauce, so why not try the drink version?

    4. Charleston Mix Bloody Mary Mix - Best Flavor Profile

    check price button
     Pros Cons
    • 32 fluid oz. 
    • No preservatives
    • Gluten-free
    • Balanced heat
    • Not suitable for vegetarians and vegans

    What Customers Have To Say

    An Amazon shopper remarked that she loves spicy bloody mary cocktails and expects to "doctor" it up no matter what mix she uses. This is not the case with this mix. She found it spicy with a bit of sweetness. 

    Another customer said that he never loved bloody mary cocktails until he had a sip of this mix. His friends are also constantly asking where to buy it.

    Why We Think It’s Great

    Whether spirited or straight, this bloody mary mix is sure to satisfy your cravings. It is made with a blend of habanero mash, apple cider vinegar, Worcestershire sauce, and other spices. It doesn't contain horseradish, MSG, or high fructose syrup. It’s also fair to mention that it has beef broth and anchovies that add a depth of flavor to the overall drink. 

    Who Should Buy It

    This bloody mary mix is perfectly balanced and gives a classic flavor. If this is your thing, then this one’s perfect for you.

    5. Zing Zang Bloody Mary Mix - Best Traditional

    Zing Zang Bloody Mary Mix

    check price button
     Pros Cons
    • 32 fluid oz. 
    • Low-calorie
    • Suitable for room temperature environments
    • It can be consumed as is
    • Lacks in flavor

    What Customers Have To Say

    An Amazon shopper considers this the best bloody mary mix because it’s not overly heavy on tomato. It’s tangy with celery seed, light, and not overpowered by horseradish. It’s her go-to bloody mary mix, and everyone she serves it to loves it. 

    Another customer commented that this is an excellent bloody mary mix because of its flavor. He uses it with Tito’s Vodka and then adds veggies and shrimp to provide a nutritious buzz. 

    Why We Think It’s Great

    Some people are very picky and have their standards on how to consume cocktails. While Zing Zang doesn’t have as big of a flavor profile as other brands, it has a silver lining since people are open to add whatever their preferences to make a bloody mary recipe. 

    Who Should Buy It

    This bloody mary mix is a good starting point for beginners since the cocktail itself is an acquired taste.

    6. Ocean Spray Bloody Mary Mix - Best Mild

    Ocean Spray Bloody Mary Mix

    check price button
     Pros Cons
    • 32 fluid oz. 
    • Excellent for customization
    • Classic flavor
    • Great for brunches
    • Spicy and thick
    • Requires other ingredients for added flavor
    • May be too thick to mix

    What Customers Have To Say

    One customer said that she finally found something that is not too hot for a bloody mary mix. It has the right amount of spices which she likes because she can't tolerate too much spices. 

    Another buyer shared that she drinks this bloody mary mix without alcohol in the morning as part of her breakfast. It is pretty thick, so it doesn't get runny when she adds the other ingredients like Worcestershire sauce and ice.

    Why We Think It’s Great

    Ocean Spray is known for its variety of juices, but they have a hidden jewel that deserves recognition: bloody mary mix. Since this brand specializes in fruit juice, it’s no wonder why this mix contains cranberry and grapefruit juice. You can even add your signature ingredients for creating different bloody mary recipes.

    Who Should Buy It

    This bloody mary mix offers 32 oz. bottles in packs of 12, so it's very sufficient for big parties or gatherings. Plus, the flavor is not robust, perfect for those who don’t like too much spice in their drink.

    7. Toma Bloody Mary Mix - Best Healthy Option

    Toma Bloody Mary Mix

    check price button
     Pros Cons
    • 32 fluid oz. 
    • Perfect for the health-conscious
    • Uses homemade hot sauce
    • Ready to drink
    • No artificial flavors and preservatives
    • Too thick to mix

    What Customers Have To Say

    Toma is worth it, according to one Amazon customer. Its flavor with a kick of spice is the perfect blend for a bloody mary. It tastes homemade and well done. A different customer agrees that this bloody mary mix has the perfect kick if you like some spice. It’s excellent with some ice. He also loves that it’s at a reasonable price point.

    Why We Think It’s Great

    This bloody mary mix is every health enthusiasts’ dream because it allows them to indulge without having to face too much consequence. It is gluten-free, vegan, low-carb, keto-friendly, and has low sodium. It is also made with sriracha and chipotle-tomatillo sauce for a different spice flavor.

    Who Should Buy It

    Even as a “healthier” version, it doesn't fall short of taste and flavor. This one has a peppery, smokey, and savory taste that makes an excellent bloody mary any time.

     

    8. V8 Bloody Mary Mix - Best for Beginners

    V8 Bloody Mary Mix

    check price button
     Pros Cons
    • 46 fluid oz. 
    • Vegetable-based
    • Packed with vitamins A and C
    • It can be consumed as is
    • Needs other ingredients for more flavor

    What Customers Have To Say

    One customer stated that she enjoys this bloody mary mix, but she also uses it for pepper steak to substitute for chopped tomatoes to make the spiciness and flavor better. A different customer also likes this bloody mary mix with or without vodka. The flavors are amazing, and it’s even better than the premium mixes.

    Why We Think It’s Great

    This bloody mary mix is made with tomato juice, celery, onion, salt, and a hint of black pepper. It has the right blend of savory goodness despite being made with vegetables only. Since it is more than the standard 32 oz. mix, one bottle of the V8 is enough to make a total of 9 cocktails.

    Who Should Buy It

    If you have a preferred hot sauce for your cocktail, you can pair it with this terrific bloody mary mix. This is also an excellent option for vegetarians and vegans.  

    9. Mr & Mrs T Original Bloody Mary Mix - Best Single-Use

     Mr & Mrs T Original Bloody Mary Mix

    check price button
     Pros Cons
    • 5.5 fluid oz.
    • Ideal for traveling
    • Made with 95% tomato juice
    • Uses cane sugar
    • It can be enjoyed as is
    • Lacks spice
    • Metal cans can have dents

    What Customers Have To Say

    A customer shared that she enjoys a good bloody mary, and this always has been and still is her favorite mixer to use. The cans are perfect single servings that give a fresh taste each time. They are also easy to throw in a beverage cooler than taking a whole big mixer bottle when traveling. 

    A different shopper commented that this is the best-tasting bloody mary mix. He never orders bloody mary in a restaurant or bar because they don’t use Mr & Mrs T, and theirs doesn’t compare to this mix’s delicious taste. 

    Why We Think It’s Great

    A mixture of tomato juice, sea salt, lemon, and coarse black pepper results in a perfect blend of the classic bloody mary. It is still open for customization, so you're free to add more ingredients that you deem fit for your cocktail. Given that it’s in individual cans, this bloody mary mix is terrific for single consumption, whether with spirits or without. 

    Who Should Buy It

    If you don’t consume bloody mary cocktails often, this bloody mary mix is a smart option. Opening a big bottle and not finishing them soon will only lead to wastage, so you better use these!

    10. Pittsburgh Pickle Company Bloody Mary Mix - Best Flavor Twist

    Pittsburgh Pickle Company Bloody Mary Mix

    check price button
     Pros Cons
    • 32 fluid oz. 
    • Award-winning
    • Distinctive bottle
    • Pickle flavor
    • All-natural ingredients
    • A bit pricey

    What Customers Have To Say

    One customer said that this bloody mary mix is every bit as tasty as the label is cool. It has a unique, bold flavor and not just the average spices and tomato juice. It also has a robust pickle juice taste that lingers on the tongue, giving a scrumptious tang. 

    Another shopper commented that this had become a staple for Sunday brunch with her boyfriend. It has just the right amount of pickle flavor. For them, it’s such a genius idea from a great small business, so she highly recommends this bloody mary mix.

    Why We Think It’s Great

    This family-made bloody mary mix has the perfect blend of spice and flavor, as you would expect from a 4-time award-winning bloody mary mix, including two Platinum Medals. For added punch, this is infused with Pittsburgh Pickle Company pickle brine that mixes well with spirits.

    Who Should Buy It

    For every purchase of this bloody mary mix, you can help a family-owned and operated business. And if you are a fan of pickles, this is the one to get.

    11. George's Old Bay Seasoned Bloody Mary Mix - Best Savory Taste

    George's Old Bay Seasoned Bloody Mary Mix

    check price button
     Pros Cons
    • 32 fluid oz. 
    • Old Bay seasoning
    • Versatile
    • Free from artificial flavorings
    • Gluten-free
    • Doesn’t cater vegetarian and vegans

    What Customers Have To Say

    An Amazon patron shared that he was born and raised in Maryland, so obviously, Old Bay goes on everything and is a staple on the table. He was so excited when he tried this bloody mary mix and said that it was delicious. 

    Another customer said that George’s would rank right at the top of his favorite bloody mary mixes. It has a good blend of ingredients, and the taste is consistent that one looks for in a proper bloody mary mix.

    Why We Think It’s Great

    If you’re from Maryland, you must be familiar with the iconic Old Bay spice. You can also have it as a bloody mary mix, which features all the essential ingredients for a classic bloody mary but with a unique twist: the sought-after blend with crab and spices. So not only can you make a good cocktail out of it, but it can also be a base for crab soup or as a marinade for dishes.

    Who Should Buy It

    This is the best bloody mary mix for anyone who loves the blend of Old Bay spice and who likes other uses for mixes.

    12. Demitri's Bloody Mary Mixes - Best Set

    Demitri's Bloody Mary Mixes

    check price button
     Pros Cons
    • 8 fluid oz.
    • Variety pack
    • It can be used for cooking
    • All-natural
    • No chemicals and artificial flavors
    • Needs tomato juice
    • High sodium content

     What Customers Have To Say

    A customer shared that he used to make bloody marys from scratch and found them delicious but time-consuming. He first had Demitri's mix at his favorite local breakfast restaurant. From then on, it’s all he ever uses, and he loves all the flavors. 

    A different shopper bought these bloody mary mixers as a gift for her husband. He liked the first time he tried them all. He was also happy to find out that he can use it for cooking too. 

    Why We Think It’s Great

    This set includes not three but four versions of bloody mary seasoning, namely, classic, chilies & peppers, extra horseradish, and chipotle-habanero. Each one is made of all-natural ingredients and has the appropriate taste and flavor according to their names. You can also use it as a marinade for grilling or salads.

    Who Should Buy It

    If you want to have unique bloody mary cocktails to serve guests or to consume every other day, this pack of bloody mary mix is for you.

    13. Powell & Mahoney Bloody Mary Mixer - Best for Vegans

    Powell&Mahoney Bloody Mary Mixers

    check price button
     Pros Cons
    • 25.36 fluid oz. 
    • Vegan
    • Organic
    • Made with cane sugar
    • Great consistency
    • May be too sweet 

    What Customers Have To Say

    One customer thought that this bloody mary mix has the right level of tomato and spice that somehow does not entirely mask the vodka. Another shopper commented that one of the best things about this is the organic ingredients. He and his girlfriend went through almost the entire bottle in one sitting. It is a little thicker than most, so they add more vodka. 

    Why We Think It’s Great

    From the line of award-winning cocktail mixers, Powell and Mahoney boasts their bloody mary mix that is crafted with the best and healthy ingredients. For a fresh and delightful cocktail with a kick, this mix is great for bars, restaurants, and homes.

    Who Should Buy It

    For people who are watching out for their health, you’ll be pleased to know that you can still indulge in a bloody mary with this mix.

    14. W&P Bloody Mary Craft Cocktail Kit - Most Unique 

    W&P Bloody Mary Craft Cocktail Kit

    check price button
     Pros Cons
    • Makes 2 drinks
    • Includes rimming salt
    • Great for individual drinking
    • Packed in a TSA-approved tin
    • Perfect gift idea
    • Still needs tomato juice 
    • Pricey

    What Customers Have To Say

    Everything about this product was perfect and beautiful for one Amazon customer. He purchased it as a gift, and he found the packaging beautifully designed. He highly recommends this as a small present for someone who travels often. Another shopper said that he buys this bloody mary mix for almost every person he knows, and they get super surprised.

    Why We Think It’s Great

    Bloody mary mixes usually come in a bottle that you store in your fridge, so you can grab it whenever you want. But what if you’re traveling? Fret not because this cute cocktail kit is what you need. It Includes the bloody mary mix, rimming salt, bar spoon, and a linen coaster - perfect for libations on the go.

    Who Should Buy It

    Whether you’re camping, having a road trip, or enjoying a picnic, this is a mess-free way to have a delightful bloody mary. It also makes an excellent gift to family and friends. 

    15. Bloody Revolution Gourmet Mixes - Most Versatile

    Bloody Revolution Gourmet Mixes

    check price button
     Pros Cons
    • 32 fluid oz. 
    • Excellent spice level
    • Suitable for gourmet cooking
    • Traditional bloody mary ingredients
    • It can be consumed as is
    • Consistency may be too thick

    What Customers Have To Say

    According to a shopper, this bloody mary mix is so good because it has an excellent taste. He highly recommends it as well as the other flavors. This was consistent with another customer’s comment of the mix being good. It also has a kick to it, and he will be buying more. 

    Why We Think It’s Great

    Before looking for other flavors, you have to try the classic ones first. And this traditional bloody mary mix is not one to disappoint. The taste is complex, and the savoriness of the vegetables comes through when paired with the delightful heat from the spices.

    Who Should Buy It

    If you enjoy the original flavor of bloody mary, Bloody Revolution is an excellent way to start. All it takes is a shot or two of vodka, and you’ll have a delicious cocktail in no time. 

    Best Bloody Mary Mix Buying Guide

    There are many kinds of bloody mary mixes out there, and to ensure that you find the best bloody mary mix that suits your needs, don’t forget to go through the factors below. 

    • Shelf life

    You should consider shelf life because you wouldn’t want your bloody mary mix to go to waste. Some bloody mary mixes can last for months, and some are only good for a couple of days. 

    Once you’ve opened a bottle of bloody mary mix, it’ll go bad quicker, just like every food product. Another thing is tomato juice. Bloody mary mixes with tomato juice, even when refrigerated, tends to spoil quickly. 

    If you want something that’ll last for months, get a bloody mary mix with no tomato juice. Your storage for the bloody mary mixes can also affect its shelf life. To keep them longer, it’s best if you store them in a cool and dark place.

    • Spice / Flavor 

    If you have a spiciness level preference for your bloody mary, you should check out the bottle first for any specifications. Bloody mary, by nature, has a hint of spice, but some mixes contain a combination of jalapeno, chile de arbol, habanero, chipotle, and ancho peppers. 

    Make sure you have an idea of how spicy a bloody mary mix is. Flavorwise, other brands like to add more ingredients to the list, such as seasonings, fruit juices, and broth, for a more savory taste.

    • Volume

    You can find a wide array of bloody mary mixes, and you’ll see that they come in different containers. Choose the right size for you. The standard bottle holds 32 ounces. If you don’t find yourself drinking a load of bloody mary in a day, choose a bloody mary mix that comes in cans instead.

    • Price

    As per usual, only purchase products you can afford. There are so many worth it bloody mary mixes out there at great price points. You just have to know where to look. Shopping for bloody mary mixes can be overwhelming because of the vast choices, and that’s why having a prepared budget is a must.

    • Ingredients

    It’s essential to check the labels and the ingredients on the bottle of a bloody mary mix before buying it because the elements are different for every brand. If you have allergies or a vegetarian or vegan, read the ingredients first.

    Bloody Mary Mix FAQ

    1. How can you make a bloody mary mix better?

    Bloody mary mixes are fantastic since they help you save so much time. They don’t taste any different than a homemade bloody mary except for the acidity and zing, but you can fix it in under two minutes. 

    To spice up the zing, try tossing in your preferred hot sauce or horseradish. On the other hand, citrus is great for adding a hint of acid. You can also try kombucha or bitters if you want to go over the top. And if you’re going to add a bit of saltiness to your bloody mary mix, pickle juice can help.

    2. What do you garnish bloody mary with?

    If you’re the type of person to stick to tradition, you should garnish your bloody mary with a lemon or lime wedge, olives, celery, and the classic salt around the rim. However, if you want to be bold and adventurous, you can put just about anything.

    You’d be surprised what people garnish their bloody mary. Dried fish, beef jerky, bacon, shrimp, waffles, sliders, fried chicken, and donuts have been tried. There are no rules with garnishes here.

    3. Does bloody mary mix go bad?

    An opened bottle of bloody mary mix will spoil quickly, while an unopened one will last for a couple of months. 

    Be wary of the ingredient because a bloody mary mix with tomato juice is best served within a week from being stored in the fridge. This is because tomato juice spoils fast. Meanwhile, you can keep a bloody mary mix without tomato juice for months.

    4. Is bloody mary healthy?

    You probably didn’t know, but bloody mary can be good for your body. It’s because of the ingredients like tomatoes, horseradish, and hot sauce. These three can strengthen your bones, fight diseases, and keep your heart healthy. 

    However, if you want to get all its benefits, you may need to throw away the vodka. Also, opt for a healthier choice of garnish. That means lay off the bacon or donuts garnish.

    5. What liquor can you put in bloody mary besides vodka?

    Vodka is like the jelly in peanut butter and jelly sandwiches. It’s original and classic, but you can substitute it with an alternative, and the result would still be great. Two of the most common vodka alternatives are gin and tequila.

    A gin-based bloody mary is called red snapper, while a tequila-based bloody mary is called a bloody maria. Some liquors to try for a bloody mary are dark rum, bourbon, soju, and jägermeister. A similar version called the michelada uses a light lager instead of vodka.

    Conclusion

    The next time you crave the complex and savory taste of bloody mary, you can spare some time by using a pre-made mix instead. It also lets you save money because you don’t have to buy the other ingredients except for the vodka. 

    You can start with the crowd-favorite Mr & Mrs T Original Bloody Mary Mix. Consume it immediately with no added components, and every sip will be fresh because it is in a single-serve can. 

    If you like to explore new flavors, try Demitri's Bloody Mary Mixes. You’ll never be bored having the same bloody mary all the time. Finally, the best bloody mary mix for you to try is the Bloody Revolution Gourmet Mixes for classic enthusiasts. If you’re not drinking it, you can use it to amp up your dishes.

     


    Older Post Newer Post


    Leave a comment

    Please note, comments must be approved before they are published