15 Best Whiskey Flavored Sauces In 2021: Reviews & Buying Guide

Reviews Whiskey

Best Whiskey Flavored Sauces

When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. For more information on how we conduct reviews, click here.

There are many different types of whiskey in the world, and some evolved to other forms like sauces. Whiskey flavored sauces offer an exciting opportunity to explore and experiment with your food or drinks.

We'll give you our picks for what we believe are the best whiskey flavored sauces available on the market today!

Our Top Picks

Best for Fish Recipes - Tastefully Simple Bayou Bourbon Glaze

• Natural ingredients
• Best for grilling
Complex but flavorful taste

Best Sweet and Spicy Flavor - Elijah’s Xtreme Reaper Hot Sauce

Award-winning sauce
Vegan and gluten-free
Fruity sweetness

Jim Beam Maple Bourbon BBQ Sauce
Check Price button mobile

Best Classic BBQ Taste - Jim Beam Maple Bourbon BBQ Sauce

Gluten-free
Fantastic zesty flair
Right consistency

1. Rufus Teague Whiskey BBQ Sauce

Rufus Teague Whiskey BBQ Sauce

check price button

 Pros Cons
  • Gluten-free
  • Non-GMO
  • Goes with any meat recipes
  • Thick consistency
  • Too sweet



What Customers Have To Say

Customers say this is an amazing sauce and is among their favorites. It has a nice bite with slightly sweet maple that goes good on pretty much anything.

Why We Think It’s Great

A deep and sweet tomato paste with onion powder, garlic powder, chili pepper powder, and molasses flavor is what you'll notice first of this sauce. The sweetness quickly becomes tangy as vinegar builds tartness but doesn't overshadow the whiskey or liquid smoke. 

A taste of molasses dominates the first few moments as a hint of maple syrup appears but doesn't last long to become overpowering. It's a smooth dark red that comes out of the jar with a medium-thick texture and without any spices visible, but once you taste it, your mouth will be filled with savory notes.

Who Should Buy It

This whiskey BBQ sauce would be great for people who like it sweeter than usual.

2. Stubb's Hickory Bourbon Whiskey BBQ Sauce

Stubb's Hickory Bourbon Whiskey BBQ Sauce

check price button

 Pros
Cons
  • No high-fructose corn syrup
  • Rich taste
  • Gluten-free
  • Balance of sweetness and heat
  • Quite watery



What Customers Have To Say

Customers are delighted with the way this sauce tastes. It has an excellent balance of sweet and tart that gets better with every bite. It’s got a very little sweet taste, which is very hard to find in a BBQ sauce.

Why We Think It’s Great

Stubb's Hickory Bourbon whiskey BBQ Sauce is the perfect solution for people who love the best bourbons and country music. This sauce brings out the flavor of your meat while adding a unique taste that only comes from using real ingredients like tamarind, cane sugar, natural hickory smoke, molasses, distilled vinegar, fresh onions, garlic, tomato, and bourbon! 

It has a vinegar tang yet smoky with hints of honey and mustard to give you all the great-tasting BBQ in one bottle. It will leave you feeling satisfied knowing that all the ingredients are thoughtfully sourced, made with better-for-you ingredients, and are verified to be gluten-free.

Who Should Buy It

This product is excellent for people who love a barbecue sauce that's not too sweet but still noticeable.

3. Bourbon Barrel Foods Worcestershire Sauce

Bourbon Barrel Foods Worcestershire Sauce

check price button

 Pros
Cons
  • Good for Vegetarians
  • All-natural recipe
  • Aged in bourbon barrels
  • Versatile usage
  • Pricy for its size



What Customers Have To Say

Shoppers couldn't believe how tasty this whiskey sauce was. It adds a depth of flavor in soups or broths, on tofu, or rice. It's not as tangy as the store brand non-fish types, but it's slightly sweet and definitely Worcestershire.

Why We Think It’s Great

The Bourbon Barrel Foods Worcestershire sauce brings the flavors of Kentucky to your table with a mellow blend of sweet sorghum, pure limestone spring water, and barrel-aged bourbon notes. 

You can enjoy this since it doesn't have any added sugar or sodium! When cooking a genuinely Southern dish, it’s perfect for adding woodsy sweetness to your barbecue sauces or meatloaves. 

Its vegetarian-friendly ingredients are an excellent addition if you follow gluten-free diets too. With its unique features combined with fantastic taste, there is no better choice between sauces.

Who Should Buy It

The Bourbon Barrel Foods Worcestershire Sauce is for people looking for a vegetarian version of their favorite condiment.

4. McCormick Bourbon Chicken Skillet Sauce

McCormick Bourbon Chicken Skillet Sauce

check price button

 Pros
Cons
  • No artificial flavors
  • No MSG
  • Great for quick meals
  • A little watery
  • Not very versatile

What Customers Have To Say

Shoppers say this is easy to heat and put over baked chicken and makes a fabulous dinner. It is tasty and so easy to get together. The price was a little high but a very special splurge and worth purchasing again.

Why We Think It’s Great

This mix will transport your taste buds straight to bourbon country. Adding McCormick's sauce makes the impossible possible, bringing Bourbon Chicken to your table in less than 20 minutes with just one pot! 

The easy garlic, onions, and ginger blend is mixed with sweet soy sauce for a delicate balance of flavor that surprises every time. This hearty blend has no artificial components or high fructose corn syrup. 

Stir some cubed chicken into it before cooking, or add any frozen vegetables on top for an even tastier meal that can't be beaten. This new recipe will make coming home time after time better than ever before!

Who Should Buy It

This whiskey sauce is for people who love saucy chicken dishes but barely have time to stir something up.

5. Kentuxican Bourbon Hot Sauce

Kentuxican Bourbon Hot Sauce

check price button

 Pros
Cons
  • Uses premium Kentucky bourbon
  • No preservatives
  • Keto-friendly and Gluten-free
  • Fantastic mix of spices
  • The bourbon flavor is not very pronounced



What Customers Have To Say

A shopper says this great sauce is perfectly balanced. It's spicy, sweet, tangy, and smoky. The heat is a little low for his taste, and he would like to see an extra spicy version of this. Another one said this is a combo of great-tasting whiskey BBQ sauce and a hot sauce.

Why We Think It’s Great

If you like chipotle and bourbon, then this is the perfect one for you. The sweet, tangy, smoky, fiery balance means that it’s, in a word, “delicious.” All of these great profiles are offset by a smooth yet spicy finish on your palette with an earthy undertone to give you the most flavorful burst possible when it hits your taste buds. 

With onions, garlic, apple cider vinegar, peppercorns, peppers, and more, this recipe takes traditional Mexican recipes infused with Kentucky-style whiskey sauce to create something truly unique. Any dish will be elevated to new heights with just a drizzle or two of this Kentuxican.

Who Should Buy It

This product is perfect for those looking for a not-so-spicy sauce.

6. Bourbon Barrel Kentuckyaki

Bourbon Barrel Kentuckyakicheck price button

 Pros
Cons
  • All-natural
  • Low sugar
  • Great for vegetarians
  • Excellent for Asian cuisine
  • It may be too salty for some



What Customers Have To Say

An Amazon shopper said it is delicious and a great alternative to his usual Kikkomann's low sodium teriyaki sauce. Kentuckyaki has less sugar and tastes just as good as the Kikkoman's, perhaps even better.

Another one uses the Kentuckyaki for her stir fry and to marinate her sautéed mushrooms. It gives so much more depth than regular soy.

Why We Think It’s Great

A unique marinade with Kentucky sorghum, bourbon, and soy sauce, this is the perfect way to boost your meal plan on busy weeknights or weekend brunches! This all-natural marinade is non-GMO, low in sugars, vegetarian friendly, and contains fresh garlic and ginger, providing a potent anti-inflammatory agent linked to multiple health benefits. 

Marinades are essential for preparing protein pieces for grilling because they help keep them moist while adding depth. This is why you should never skip out on your barbecue sauce or dry rubs! 

Mix up one of the signature recipes like Bourbon Barrel Kentuckyaki Grillables for flavorful chicken breasts, zesty shrimp kebabs, and roast pork tenderloins.

Who Should Buy It

The Bourbon Barrel Kentuckyaki is great for vegetarian people and wouldn't mind paying a higher price for a good quality sauce.

7. Lynchburg Tennessee Whiskey BBQ Sauce

Lynchburg Tennessee Whiskey BBQ Sauce

check price button

 Pros
Cons
  • Keto-friendly
  • Less salt content
  • No MSG
  • Low carb and sugar-free
  • A little runny



What Customers Have To Say

A shopper said this is the best sugar-free sauce he's ever had. Meanwhile, another one has been looking for a good whiskey BBQ sauce to eat while on keto since every other sauce he's tried so far has a strong artificial sweetener taste. This sauce tastes like regular whiskey bbq sauce that has more vinegar taste than sweetness.

Why We Think It’s Great

Lynchburg Tennessee Whiskey Sauce is a sugar-free, authentic whiskey BBQ sauce, perfect for your next backyard bbq. This unique sauce comes in the shape of a whiskey bottle and boasts tomato paste, apple cider vinegar, and Worcestershire sauce, making it one refreshing taste to cook with any meat recipe. 

This diabetic-friendly sauce also contains great spices like chipotle peppers, garlic cloves, onion powder, cinnamon sticks, and other secret spice blends.

Who Should Buy It

This sauce is perfect for people who have diabetes and are on a keto diet.

8. Johnny's Whiskey Sauce

Johnny's Whiskey Sauce

check price button

 Pros
Cons
  • Great for protein recipes
  • Balanced flavor profile
  • Unique bottle design
  • The bottle needs to be bigger


What Customers Have To Say

Customers say this is an incredibly delicious sauce and one of the tastiest bbq sauces. The whiskey stands out, and there is a perfect sweet and heat balance. You get what you pay for the quality and deliciousness provided. It also has quite a zing to it but is not so hot.

Why We Think It’s Great

Johnny invented this genius concoction because of his devotion to bold flavors. He took a shot of whiskey and another from a pot with a little molasses and a pinch of cracked black pepper, and there came the birth of Johnny's Whiskey Sauce. 

This mild sauce tastes good with meat, pasta, or vegetables. It is perfect for any time of the year, and it goes great in any recipe. Molasses and cracked black pepper are mixed to perfection in this versatile flavor. You can also mix some Johnny's whiskey sauce into stews, perfect for autumn.

Who Should Buy It

Johnny's Whiskey Sauce is excellent for those who appreciate a great flavored sauce and can let a pricey cost slide.

9. Tastefully Simple Bayou Bourbon Glaze

Tastefully Simple Bayou Bourbon Glaze

check price button

 Pros
Cons
  • Natural ingredients
  • Best for grilling
  • Used for any protein recipe
  • Complex but flavorful taste
  • The bottle's structural integrity is weak



What Customers Have To Say

An Amazon shopper bought this one based on the reviews since he's not an expert on this kind of sauce. Fortunately, he was not disappointed. Another one said the flavor is perfect, and it has a little zing but not so much. It's flavorful, but it doesn’t require a considerable amount to get the full flavor.

Why We Think It’s Great

Tastefully Simple Bayou Bourbon Glaze is considered a best-kept secret. This sauce has just the right amount of bourbon for a rich, tangy flavor with apple cider vinegar, molasses, and brown sugar. Make it your go-to glaze to pour over meats, poultry, seafood, or your favorite vegetables. 

Use it in marinades or stir fry dips to get that extra pizzazz that will take any meal to its next level. The gourmet ingredients are concocted together to create an all-natural sauce without any artificial preservatives, making this perfect for festive occasions like cocktail parties and holiday dinners.

Who Should Buy It

It is ideal for people who are looking for a whiskey sauce or glaze that is all-natural.

10. Jack Daniel's Whiskey BBQ Sauce

Jack Daniel's Whiskey BBQ Sauce

check price button

 Pros
Cons
  • Gluten-free
  • Made with Jack Daniel's whiskey
  • Excellent for pork recipes
  • Reports of brand mixups


What Customers Have To Say

An Amazon customer said this sauce makes everything taste great. Another shopper said it pairs perfectly with ribs and pulled pork.

Why We Think It’s Great

If this is your first foray into the world of barbecue sauces, you couldn’t do better than Jack Daniel's barbecue sauce. It's effortless to use and cook with, and it doesn't matter if you're grilling on an electric or a gas grill. 

It's made with essential barbecue ingredients like brown sugar, ketchup, spices, other flavorings, and of course, Jack Daniel's Tennessee Whiskey. Just add some of the spicy variety to beef and grilled onions, and you’ve got yourself some whole new flavor elements in your life.

Who Should Buy It

This sauce is perfect for people who are avid fans of Jack Daniel's.

11. Whiskey Barrel Aged Shoyu Soy Sauce

Whiskey Barrel Aged Shoyu Soy Sauce

check price button

 Pros
Cons
  • Sufficient sweetness
  • Shelf-stable
  • Aged in Mizunara Japanese whisky oak barrels
  • Rich umami flavor
  • A bit salty



What Customers Have To Say

An Amazon customer said this was incredible with a delightfully complex flavor. The taste is unlike any other soy sauce he has ever experienced. Another customer said this was by far the best soy sauce she's tried!

Why We Think It’s Great

The Japanese are known for their impeccable cuisine, and this sauce is a testament to that. The complexity of soy mixed with the mellow notes from whiskey makes this an ingredient worth trying. 

The 750-ml bottle will last you when you need something special or want to impress your guests with a delicious recipe. Try enhancing your ramen soup with a shot of this tasty Japanese soy sauce, or use it as a dipping sauce for shumai dumplings.

Who Should Buy It

This is a great product for anyone looking to buy a special soy sauce with more depth and enhanced with whiskey.

12. Elijah’s Xtreme Reaper Hot Sauce

Elijah’s Xtreme Reaper Hot Sauce

check price button

 Pros
Cons
  • Award-winning sauce
  • All-natural
  • Vegan and gluten-free
  • Boasts fruity sweetness
  • Too sweet and not as spicy to some



What Customers Have To Say

An Amazon customer said that what makes this sauce unique is its interesting blend of ingredients. It gives you the sensations of the pepper just without the drama. It's like a light coat of flame inside your mouth. 

Another customer said he loves the balance of favor and heat in this sauce. The bourbon, black cherries, and cranberries make this smooth as silk. 

Why We Think It’s Great

Elijah’s Xtreme is the sweet and spicy way you want your food. As professional chefs know, sauces can be used to give depth of flavor to any meal, whether it's subtle or extreme, so there's sure to be something for every palate. 

This uncompromising sauce has garnered a whopping 15 Industry Awards and has about 250,000 - 350,000 Scoville units. It is made with fresh ingredients free from artificial flavors or preservatives while remaining vegan and gluten-free. 

There are no limits on how this versatile sauce should taste, which means it can accompany anything from grilled meat to Baja tacos without sacrificing taste.

Who Should Buy It

This sauce is excellent for people who love sweetness with spiciness and those on a vegan diet.

13. Fighting Cock Kentucky Bourbon BBQ Sauce

Fighting Cock Kentucky Bourbon BBQ Sauce

check price button

 Pros
Cons
  • Made with Kentucky bourbon
  • Balance of zest and heat
  • An excellent alternative to ketchup
  • Thin consistency


What Customers Have To Say

An Amazon customer said this zesty sauce has just enough heat to be flavorful but not enough to set you on fire. This is great on ribs and pulled pork and tasty on steak and chops. Another customer said this is the right bbq sauce for anything bbq. It has the perfect balance of sweetness and heat.

Why We Think It’s Great

Fighting Cock Kentucky Bourbon BBQ Sauce is perfect for your next outdoor barbecue, tailgate party, or camping trip. If you are looking to throw the ultimate bourbon grilling experience, this sauce has everything you need. 

It has a rich and smooth flavor with hints of hickory smoke and cola that pair perfectly with meats like brisket. The great thing about Fighting Cock Kentucky Bourbon BBQ Sauce is that it’s versatile. 

It can be used as an appetizer dip or as a flavoring like baby bbq sauce by adding some boiling water to achieve the consistency needed.

Who Should Buy It

The Fighting Cock Kentucky is ideal for those looking for a versatile whiskey BBQ sauce with a perfectly balanced spiciness and sweetness.

14. Magic Pine Whiskey BBQ Sauce

Magic Pine Whiskey BBQ Sauce

check price button

 Pros
Cons
  • A bit runny


What Customers Have To Say

An Amazon customer said this definitely has a unique flavor profile, a bit tangy, sweet, and smoky at the same time. He's used it for chicken, beef, and even vegetables and has tasted great on everything so far. Another customer purchased this as a gift, and the person he gave it to loves it!

Why We Think It’s Great

There’s nothing sadder than a barbecue sauce recipe devoid of flavor and nothing more satisfying than one with depth like this one. This whiskey-based BBQ sauce is a perfect blend of smoky and sweet. 

It's made from natural ingredients such as Habanero chiles, molasses, ginger, garlic, and whiskey, adding richness while enhancing the subdued smokiness you enjoy in bourbon or other beverages.

Who Should Buy It

This product is for people planning to give away a great gift to a loved one, especially if they love BBQ.

15. Jim Beam Maple Bourbon BBQ Sauce

Jim Beam Maple Bourbon BBQ Sauce

check price button

 Pros
Cons
  • All-natural
  • Gluten-free
  • Fantastic zesty flair
  • Right consistency
  • A bit on the sweeter side



What Customers Have To Say

An Amazon customer said this sauce is perfect as it is not too tangy and has a nice consistency. The maple and bourbon flavors are present but not overpowering. Another customer said this was flavorsome. It works well with chicken, beef, or pork, making it her go-to sauce.

Why We Think It’s Great

The Jim Beam Maple Bourbon is one of the best-tasting, most flavorful barbecue sauces you can find anywhere. This classic blend of maple syrup and brown sugar creates a delectable sweet flavor with just the right amount of spice to keep your chicken wings or pork chops from becoming too saucy. 

Whether you're using this as an all-natural baster for your next grill out or need it as a secret ingredient in one of your favorite recipes, this high-quality BBQ sauce recipe will make sure that everything sizzles like it's supposed to!

Who Should Buy It

This product is great for people who like their BBQ sauce on the sweeter side.

Best Whiskey Flavored Sauce Buying Guide

Looking for the right whiskey sauce is like finding the best whiskeys. You need to look at several aspects like the ones below and incorporate your preferences.

  • Flavor

Perhaps the most essential thing that matters in food is flavor and smell. Most whiskey sauces are in the form of barbecue sauce, which is supposed to have a balance of sweetness, savoriness, tanginess, and smokiness. Sometimes, a little bit of kick will improve the flavor.

  • Texture / Consistency

Sauces are mainly used for coating or dipping, so their texture must be smooth and thick enough to cover the food. When it's too thick or sticky, you may end up putting more than you need.

  • Appearance

Sauces come in all shades of yellow, red, and brown. But whatever color it is, it must look appetizing and suitable for presentation and taste.

  • Price

This is dependent upon the bottle size and the components of the whiskey sauce. They're usually affordable, but if you want your money's worth, you may choose those that come in sets for a better deal.

Whiskey Flavored Sauce FAQ

1. What foods go well with a whiskey flavored sauce?

You can usually use them for barbeque, either as a finishing sauce or a marinade. You can also add it to other savory foods like chicken, burgers, tacos, baked beans, sliders, and dips.

2. What imparts the whiskey flavor in these sauces?

Some options contain real whiskey or bourbon, while others are only aged in bourbon barrels that impart the whiskey flavor.

3. How many calories are in a whiskey sauce?

One serving of sauce usually is two tablespoons, which contains about 60 - 70 calories, depending on the brand.

Conclusion 

Enjoying an excellent whiskey-flavored sauce is a great way to show your love for whiskey in the food you eat, as it takes any dish up a notch. If you're having a hard time choosing among the options above, we suggest these picks.

If you're a fan of grilling and salmon, look no further than Tastefully Simple Bayou Bourbon Glaze. Meanwhile, Elijah’s Xtreme Reaper is the perfect choice if you enjoy the mix of sweet and fruity sweetness. Finally, Jim Beam Maple Bourbon barbecue sauce is the go-to for every barbecue event you have.

If you want to pair your food with a drink, try the best whiskeys inspired by celebrities!


Older Post Newer Post


Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published