10 Best Cocktail Muddlers: Reviews & Buying Guide

Table of Contents

Muddling is a bar technique used to break the mint or fruit to release its aroma and flavors. Muddled herbs make their flavors and aroma stand out. But when mixing herbs, especially mint and basil, do not over muddle as it tends to be bitter and will affect the taste of the cocktail. 

When muddling, the best way to do it is to press and twist. Another important thing is to understand your ingredients. Some herbs cannot stand heavy crushing. The resulting cocktail would be bitter as more essential oils were released and broken instead of heightened. 

    10 Best Cocktail Muddlers

    Here’s a review of the most popular muddlers on Amazon and how they really work. Take some time to read before making a purchase.

    1. Best mojito muddler: Fletcher's Mill Maple Muddler 

    Fletcher's Mill Maple Muddler - AdvancedMixology

    At 11" long, it is just the right length to crush your ingredients like herbs without hurting your knuckles on the glass rim. It is made by artisans from farmed wood using energy-efficient carving and finishing tools. It also doubles as a mallet for making nice crushed ice. The design is just enough to get a nice grip without straining the hand and wrist.

    Reviews, however, showed that this wooden cocktail muddler cracked after some time; some even claimed after a single-use only. It is also untreated which is understandable since oiling might affect the flavor of the drink. 

    2. Best cocktail muddler for mint leaves:  BlueSkyBos Stainless Steel Cocktail Muddler

    BlueSkyBos Stainless Steel Cocktail Muddler - AdvancedMixology

    Made of stainless steel material with an ABS plastic head with teeth for better mixing of fruits, sugar and herbs. Wide tip of the handle makes it easy to hold as you muddle. It also comes with a stainless steel 2-in-1 spoon and fork for stirring cocktails. It also gives good value for its price. 

    Reviews showed that over time the junction of the stainless steel and the plastic rusted over. It is also too short to use in a cocktail tin; it needs a separate squat glass to muddle a single cocktail. It is weighted so care must be taken when using it as it may break or crack the glass. 

    3. Best cocktail muddler for sugar:  Bamber Wood Cocktail Wooden Muddler

    Bamber Wood Cocktail Wooden Muddler - AdvancedMixology

    Crush your sugar better with this toothed wooden muddler from Bamber. It is easy to clean, though it has to be hand-washed since it is not allowed in the dishwasher. Some clients claimed that this wooden muddler works better than metal muddlers. It is also sturdy and durable enough to use in crushing ice and other stuffs. 

    A bit short at 8", it seems to be the only complaint of the clients for this wooden cocktail muddler. Though we can see that cleaning the teeth is very important so that no ingredients are left between them that may cause the growth of molds. Brushing in between the teeth will remove all the debris. 

    4. Best Stainless Steel Muddler: Oxo  Stainless Steel Muddler with Non-Scratch Nylon Head

    Oxo Steel Muddler with Non-Scratch Nylon Head - AdvancedMixology

    Instead of the standard ABS plastic, it used a nylon front to protect the glass. The handle is soft and comfortable to hold and is dishwasher-safe. 

    The metal cap can be easily broken off and is flimsy. The clients claimed that it is of poor quality. It does not do the job of actual mixing

    5. Best Bamboo Muddler: Mojito Muddler 11" Professional-grade Bamboo Muddler

    Mojito Muddler 11" Professional-grade Bamboo Muddler - AdvancedMixology

    This bamboo muddler is just the right length for easy manipulation when mixing. It has grooves that make it easy to grip. It is also very easy to clean and is very durable. No lacquer or oil was applied to it that may affect the quality of the drinks.

    However, the markings on the muddler itself say it is 100% bamboo-laminated. Also, it looks like the wooden parts that were glued together and it cracked after a few uses. Other clients also said that it was too big. 

    6. Best Home Bar Muddler: Twine Acacia Cocktail Muddler

    Twine Acacia Muddler - AdvancedMixology

    The ergonomic design and the flat handle makes it easy to use when muddling. Made from beechwood, this muddler also comes with a canvas pouch for safekeeping. Most of the clients who reviewed said that the product is very sturdy and is of good value based on its price and functionality.

    However, there are also reports of cracks after a few uses. 

    7. Best Value Muddler: HQY Stainless Steel Cocktail Muddler

    HQY Stainless Steel Cocktail Muddler - AdvancedMixology

    Muddle your way to the best cocktails with this 8" long stainless steel muddler with silicone head. The front is toothed, making it perfect for all mixing jobs behind the bar. Throw it into the dishwasher and you got one less item to hand wash after a busy day. At less than $10, it is a great value buy that will last for years to come. 

    A bit short for use in large shakers and tall glasses, though, and the silicone head can flake off after some time when used to mix sugar. It could have used bigger teeth for proper crushing of hard substances too. 

    8. Best Long Muddler: Extra Long Cocktail Muddler

    Extra Long Cocktail Muddler - AdvancedMixology

    When an 8-inch or 11-inch long muddler is not enough, you might as well go overboard and get a 12-inch one. Relax your hand and wrist more with the ergonomic handle sized just right for your hand. No more bruised knuckles with the long muddler even if you're using a 24-oz cocktail shaker.

    Other bartenders were not very comfortable with the size, though, thinking it was overkill. It could have used some teeth too since the front is too flat to do some real mixing. 

    9. Best Compact Muddler: Stainless Steel Cocktail Muddler

    Stainless Steel Cocktail Muddler - AdvancedMixology

    Give yourself a break from all the bulky muddlers with this 8-inch stainless steel muddler. Rest your wrist and press your ingredients down with just the thumb. The toothed head means less pressure. No flaking of plastic or silicone parts, no parts falling apart or cracking. Just hours and hours of fun making your favorite drinks. Also durable enough for crushing ice too. 

    Not many complaints on this muddler show just how perfect it does its job. 

    10. Best Muddler Bar Tool Set: 10" Stainless Steel Cocktail Muddler & Mixing Spoon

    10" Stainless Steel Cocktail Muddler & Mixing Spoon - AdvancedMixology

    Get more cocktails done with this muddler and mixing spoon set. The muddler is sized just right to be used in tall glasses without being too bulky. Grooves on the ABS plastic front means less pressure when muddling. The handle is sized just right for comfortable handling. 

    However, cleaning comes a bit tricky as liquids tend to get between the seam. The photos also seem to advert some printed book but there is no such thing which makes it pretty much deceptive and disappointing to those who expected it. 


    1. What makes a good muddler?

    The good cocktail muddler is one that is most comfortable to use by the user. Each user has his preference that may be influenced by others' opinion but in the end, his comfort should be of utmost priority. 

    A good muddler should not put unnecessary strain to his hand and wrist when mixing, is sturdy and durable enough for years of use, and can be used in crushing. It should also be easy to clean and maintain. If it is sturdy enough to be used as a mallet, then it is a bonus. 

    2. What is a Portland muddle?

    Portland muddle is the result of mixing your ingredients like herbs with ice, resulting in poorly muddled ingredients and a watered-down cocktail. 

    3. Can I muddle without a muddler? 

    Others may think that a blender is the best choice, but a blender turns the fruit into a puree. The next best choice is a wooden spoon or ladle. 

    4. Do I need a muddler? 

    To make a proper old-fashioned, you need a muddler. Herbs can pass without a muddler, but sugar and fruits need one. 

    5. What drinks require a muddler? 

    Drinks that need a muddler are mojito, caipirinha, caipiroska, mint julep, Old Fashioned, and smash cocktails


    Muddling makes the cocktails such as the Old Fashioned and mojitos more special. Imagine an Old Fashioned without that cube of sugar or a mojito without muddled mint leaves. Sure, you can use a wooden ladle but it seems never enough. It makes it less professional-looking too. You can't entertain in your home bar making mojitos and using a wooden ladle. If you need help perfecting your crushing to make your favorite drinks, read on here.

    Older Post Newer Post

    Leave a comment

    Please note, comments must be approved before they are published